Your email is not valid
Recipient's email is not valid
Submit Close

Your email has been sent.

Click here to send another

Herod’s Edifice Complex

The great Judean builder and his outsized ego are the subject of a monumental Israel Museum exhibit

Print Email
Restoration work on the upper story of Herod’s mausoleum at the Israel Museum, Jerusalem. (Andrei Vainer; all images courtesy of the The Israel Museum)
Related Content

Hasidism, in Living Color

Jerusalem’s Israel museum persuasively shows that Hasidism is not only, or even really, about religion

Elevated

The Israel Museum’s impressive $100 million renovation awkwardly attempts to redefine the Jewish world

There’s another, wider sense of restoration here, as well. These sites, which represent perfectly the extreme historical density of Israel (which is kind of like a country-sized palimpsest), are once again Herod’s. Much of what Herod built was later seized, built upon, destroyed, renovated, destroyed again, and so on. These layers of history are interrelated in all sorts of complicated and interesting ways, but the later narratives have often come to “own” the site: If you’ve visited Masada, you probably heard plenty about the Roman assault and the Jewish rebels’ mass suicide and very little about Herod’s greatness. Masada, though, was built by Herod (who in turn had captured it from Alexander Jannaeus), and all the bits that stupefy—gigantic aqueduct in the middle of a desert; vast quarries and storehouses; three-tiered palace on the side of a cliffare his doing. The Jewish rebels’ architectural contribution here is limited to building a shul and trashing the place.

Or consider Caesarea, a city essentially founded by Herod, who built a magnificent port/temple/market/theater/hippodrome. And while Herod hasn’t exactly gone unacknowledged, he’s got a lot of successors vying for historical primacy: The city and the sites have, over the course of the last two millennia, been subject to many, many landlords. The Romans of the Byzantine Period. The Arabs of the Rashidum Caliphate. Louis IX fortified the walls but could not keep out the Baybars. The Crusaders were displaced by the Mamluks. More recently, the city was populated by Bosniak immigrants, until, finally, everything was more or less purchased outright by the Rothschilds (who, under a unique and strange agreement with the state of Israel, maintain semi-autonomous control). By scraping some of the later layers off and demonstrating Herod’s essential and visionary contributions, the exhibit attempts to reascribe the sites’ glory to their founder. It’s a sort of historical archaeology.

And approaching history from the bottom up is an awfully instructive way to do it. The Second Temple is usually thought of primarily as a religious structure—and it’s monumental in both the religious and structural sense, to be sure—but it’s arguably even more interesting as a study of Herodian politics. Herod’s Jewish roots were extremely iffy—his father was Idumean, his mother a converted Nabatean—and the Pharisees, the dominant Jewish sect of the era, refused to recognize Herod’s Judaism as legitimate. This, according to historians, caused Herod no end of grief, and throughout his life he sought to prove his religious pedigree to himself and others. So, he rebuilt the Temple, the holiest man-made structure in Judaism and one the largest, most ornate buildings in Jewish history. And while Herod was for the most part respectful of Jewish sensibilities and strictures—he employed Kohanim to build in the areas forbidden to everyone else—he was also unwaveringly loyal to Rome: As homage, he installed an enormous golden eagle over one of the Temple’s main gates, which really irked the Jewish population. Yes, the Temple was one of the holiest and most ambitious architectural projects of its time, but it also represents a complex interplay of motivations and loyalties and appeasements, which this exhibit, with its braided Jewish and Roman strains, is wonderfully attentive to.

Which is true in a larger sense, as well: At the (complimentary) lunch after the press preview, two Israeli journalists at my table fought for a solid 45 minutes over whether Herod was a villain or hero. Yes, he put a lot of people to death, including his own children and a good fraction of his 10 wives, out of jealousy or suspicion or some equally petty motive. (One of the walls of the exhibit displays a quote, attributed to Augustus: “I would rather be Herod’s pig than Herod’s son.”) And anytime an ego as prodigious as Herod’s is matched with limitless power, you’ve got trouble: Herod ordered that, when he died, the 70-member Sanhedrin should be put to death so as to guarantee widespread mourning. (This was never carried out.) That we leave with the question “What do we really think about the guy?” being less answerable than when we walked in is, I think, testament to the exhibit’s depth and poise.

***

Like this article? Sign up for our Daily Digest to get Tablet Magazine’s new content in your inbox each morning.

1 2View as single page
Print Email
DSarna says:

This was an interesting article. But I have a question, “what, pray tell, are Palestinian territories? And for that matter, what is Palestine, if not the Roman name for Israel?

ginzy1 says:

“…Herodium is now part of the Palestinian territories…”

I believe you are wrong on that point. I am reasonably certain that Herodion (as it is more commonly spelled & pronounced,, especially in Hebrew) is in Area “C” which puts it exclusively under Israeli control. Indeed there is a small IDF camp near the base of the Western slope of the mountain.

I might also add, that a custom has evolved in Gush Etzion (at least 15 years old) to go Herodion on the night of Tisha B’av to read Eicha, in the same synagogue used by those who escaped from Jerusalem to Herodion during the Great Revolt of 68-70 CE. Indeed from the top of the mountain one has a clear view of Jerusalem and the Temple Mount and so it is reasonable to assume that the escapees actually saw the fires that destroyed the 2nd Temple from the vantage point of Herodion’s summit.

Regarding the exhibit, it is quite masterful. If you are the type to read the blurb under each item (as I am) then allow yourself at least 2 hours to see the exhibit.

hg
Jerusalem / Efrat

gukibupytew says:

my best friend’s step-aunt makes $88 an hour on the laptop. She has been laid off for five months but last month her pay was $14959 just working on the laptop for a few hours. Read more on  Zap22.c­om

Noah Wiener says:

In commemoration of the scholarship of Ehud Netzer, Biblical Archaeology Society made a special collection of his articles on Herodian archaeology available for free, including the posthumously published “In Search of Herod’s Tomb,” a piece that sits at the heart of the Israel Museum exhibit Herod the Great—The King’s Final Journey: http://www.biblicalarchaeology.org/daily/archaeology-today/archaeologists-biblical-scholars-works/ehud-netzer-publications-available-to-public/

2000

Your comment may be no longer than 2,000 characters, approximately 400 words. HTML tags are not permitted, nor are more than two URLs per comment. We reserve the right to delete inappropriate comments.

Thank You!

Thank you for subscribing to the Tablet Magazine Daily Digest.
Please tell us about you.

The King’s Final Journey

Herod the Great at the Israel Museum