Your email is not valid
Recipient's email is not valid
Submit Close

Your email has been sent.

Click here to send another

Axis of Evil

A new book examines how the Nazis tailored their message for Arab and Muslim audiences

Print Email
The Mufti of Jerusalem meeting with Hitler in 1941. (Wikimedia Commons)

If you want to get even more depressed about the prospects for peace in the Middle East, check out a Web page maintained by the Anti-Defamation League that offers excerpts from the Hamas charter. One of the remarkable things about this document is the way it fuses three originally separate varieties of Jew-hatred. The first comes from the Koran, in which Jews are represented as opponents of Mohammed and thus as eternal enemies of Islam: “The prophet, prayer and peace be upon him, said: ‘The time will not come until Muslims will fight the Jews (and kill them); until the Jews hide behind rocks and trees, which will cry: O Muslim! there is a Jew hiding behind me, come on and kill him.’”

The second strain comes from 19th-century Europe, where religious Jew-hatred had given way to modern anti-Semitic conspiracy theories. Thus the Hamas charter states that Jews “control the world media [and use their] wealth to stir revolutions… They stood behind the French and the Communist Revolutions… They also used the money to establish clandestine organizations which are spreading around the world, in order to destroy societies and carry out Zionist interests.” (Among these Zionist front organizations, you will be interested to learn, are the Rotary Club, the Lions, and B’nai Brith.)

Last but not least, the Hamas charter incorporates the 20th-century rhetoric of apocalyptic anti-Zionism. “Today it is Palestine and tomorrow it may be another country or other countries. For Zionist scheming has no end, and after Palestine they will covet expansion from the Nile to the Euphrates.” It follows that peace between Israel and Arab countries is, by definition, impossible: “Leaving the circle of conflict with Israel is a major act of treason and it will bring curse on its perpetrators.”

Koranic anti-Judaism, European anti-Semitism, Arab anti-Zionism: mix them together and you have an intoxicatingly paranoid worldview, in which Jews are all-powerful and totally malevolent, and Israel is not just a state but the latest incarnation of an eternal evil. You have, in fact, a 21st-century version of Nazism. The revelation of Jeffrey Herf’s new book, Nazi Propaganda in the Arab World, is that this affinity is not coincidental. Rather, between 1939 and 1945, Germany tirelessly used radio and print media to spread Nazi ideas about the Jews to Arab countries, especially Egypt. Herf, who is a historian of Nazi Germany and not a student of Arabic or Arab history, makes clear that his book is not a study of the way this propaganda was actually received. But simply by documenting, in great and horrible detail, what the Nazis were telling the Arabs about the Jews, he raises the question of whether “the impact of fascism and Nazism on the Middle East [is] inseparable from contemporary political controversies about anti-Semitism, radical Islam, ‘Islamofascism,’ and international terrorism since the attacks of September 11, 2001.”

The key source for Nazi Propaganda in the Arab World are transcriptions of German and Italian radio broadcasts made by experts at the American Embassy in Cairo. Between September 1941 and March 1945, the embassy sent the State Department weekly reports on “Axis Broadcasts in Arabic.” After the war, these transcripts, totaling thousands of pages, ended up the National Archives, and Herf is the first historian to consult them extensively. In addition to showing just what these broadcasts said, Herf puts them into historical context, showing how the German message evolved in response to wartime events. As the author of a definitive study of the Nazis’ domestic propaganda, Herf is also able to show how the Nazi message was specifically tailored for Arab and Muslim listeners.

Before World War II, German attempts to reach out to the Muslim world were made very awkward by the Nazis’ racial doctrines, which held Arabs, Persians, and Turks to be biologically inferior to Aryans. In Mein Kampf, Hitler openly declared, “I am prevented by mere knowledge of the racial inferiority of these so-called ‘oppressed nations’ from linking the destiny of my own people with theirs.” Accordingly, the Nazis frowned on marriage between Germans and Muslims; in 1935, the Hitler Youth expelled a boy whose father was Turkish, leading to a public-relations disaster in Turkey. When the 1936 Olympics were held in Germany, Egypt and Iran threatened to boycott to express their insulted racial pride. Significantly, what smoothed over these diplomatic quarrels were the Nazis’ assurances, private and public, that their anti-Semitism was directed solely against Jews, not against other Semitic peoples.

Once the war began, Germany turned its attention to the Muslim world in earnest. In particular, the Arab countries of the Middle East and North Africa were important to the Nazis’ geopolitical designs. During World War I, the British had inspired the Arabs to revolt against Ottoman Turkey with promises of independence. But when peace came, the region was divided up between the British and French empires, breeding a resentment among the Arabs comparable to the Germans’ feelings about the Treaty of Versailles. Adding fuel to the fire was the Balfour Declaration, in which the British promised to support a Jewish home in Palestine.

The key themes of Nazi propaganda, accordingly, were anti-imperialism and anti-Zionism, with a sideline in anti-Communism. It may seem incredible that, at the very moment Germany was occupying almost every country in Europe—and exploiting them for slave labor—it could pose to the Arabs as a champion of native peoples against foreign rule. But in some quarters, the Arab resentment of Britain was so intense that Germany could be taken for a potential liberator.

The Nazis found a valuable ally, for instance, in Haj Amin el-Husseini, the Grand Mufti of Jerusalem, who found refuge in Berlin after fighting the British in Palestine and Iraq. Germany’s Arabic-language radio made great use of Husseini’s speeches, such as the one he delivered in Berlin in 1943, explaining that the Jews “lived like a sponge among peoples, sucked their blood, seized their property, undermined their morals…. All this has brought the hostility of the world down on them and nourished the Jew’s hatred against all the peoples that had been burning for two thousand years.” As Herf notes, despite spending the war as a guest of Hitler and Himmler, the Mufti was never tried for war crimes, but returned to Egypt as a national hero.

One of the things Husseini and Hitler talked about, when they met in November 1941, was their plans for the Jews in Palestine and throughout the Middle East. Hitler, who still hoped that he was on the verge of a quick victory over Stalin, promised that once the USSR fell, German forces would cross the Caucasus mountains and proceed to the “destruction of the Jewish element” in the Middle East. That plan was blocked by the resistance of the Red Army, but eight months later, when Rommel’s Afrika Korps invaded Egypt, it seemed that the Nazis might reach Palestine from the west instead. At that desperate moment for the Allies, German radio issued a broadcast in Egypt whose title was “Kill the Jews Before They Kill You.” “It is the duty of the Egyptians to annihilate the Jews and to destroy their property,” the announcer said. “Egypt can never forget that it is the Jews who are carrying out Britain’s imperialist policy in the Arab countries and that they are the source of all the disasters, which have befallen the countries of the East.” If it were not for Montgomery’s victory at El Alamein, it is certain that the Holocaust would have extended to Palestine and North Africa. In fact, the SS had already set up an Einsatzgruppe for the region, like the ones that initiated the Holocaust in Eastern Europe.

Given the extreme vulnerability of the Jews in Palestine, and the utter destruction being visited on the Jews in Europe, what is most striking in the Nazis’ Arabic-language propaganda is the unquestioning assumption of Jewish power. Again and again, the British and the Americans are described as pawns of the Jews; Roosevelt is alternately said to be Jewish or surrounded by Jews (including Eleanor); Chaim Weizmann is considered as powerful as Roosevelt and Churchill put together. “Had it not been for the Jews, neither London, Washington, nor Moscow would have been linked together,” explained one broadcast in December 1943. It is a perfect example of the Nazi “Big Lie,” for of course the truth is exactly the opposite: it was Germany’s aggression that brought together those unlikely allies.

Reading Nazi Propaganda for the Arab World is a reminder of how powerful such lies can be. They are so shameless, so contrary to every evident fact, that they seem to render facts meaningless. If you could believe, for instance, that following the American landings in North Africa, “the Jews” bestowed on Eisenhower the title “the Glittering Sword of Israel”; or that on the way home from the Tehran Conference, Roosevelt and Churchill stopped in Jerusalem to confer with their Zionist masters; or that the tiny Jewish settlement in Palestine was the nucleus of a planned Jewish empire that would include the entire Middle East and all of North Africa—then what wouldn’t you believe?

Herf does not show that such Nazi propaganda claims were actually accepted by Arab listeners, and surely the vast majority discounted them. But sadly, as the Hamas charter shows, we have not yet heard the end of the ideas whose birth Herf documents in this frightening, necessary book.

Print Email
Carlos says:

What is also amazing is how the Arabs keep using the big lie and the Western press falls for it, such as the non-existent Jenin Massacre.

Obviously Judaism has more veracity and established tyes with Western civilization than “Hamas”,we have known the Jews for much longer.But to say that the Media needs to always take the Jewish interpetation of History and existence at face value is preposterous.We know that many Arabs are extremist, so what, they are only speaking up for their side.We should be able to take up the information and” look behind the scene” and judge reality for ourselves.The Middle East does not have any Democracy.Over here we have democracy controlled by money, this too is infair! Israel has a right to defend herself,she was established by many well meaning people of Christian as well as Jewish perspektive.In times past, most Jews have been quite suppoetive of Liberal ideas, especially when they were the beneficieries.This is normal.This gave our country a true friend in the Middle east, and I support it’s right to survive, as my father did.The Christian minorities and the “Bahaii”, are quite lucky to be living in a Jewish nation, look how they are treated elsewhere.But now,the Yehudim have taken a more bellicose mentality.They have aligned themselves with the less moderate right-wingers and rascists in America.The Christian Zionists have an agenda for here in America and in the middle east.The Jewish rascists murdered “Rabin”. like the amerikan racists killed Kennedy. and that is Yisroel’s ally.For shame.The whole world is always in need of redemption, and religious absolutism is one of the causes.Now many Jews and their acolytes only care for the Jews.Of course the Muslim Terrorism is worse, they are jealous of the material wealth of the west.Is this our fault?Is this Israel’s fault no.Not alone.In Israel the daily terrorism has given birth to a more hateful mentality, which gives birth to more hate on the other side.Where did it start? Is this, an important question? Here inb the Estados Unidos we are also divided and blinded by fear.Also hatred of each other ,who is giving comfort to the enemy? Who is the enemy? The opponant comes from many angles ,as well as within.Saying that you don’t like the media, is saying nothing.You can always read something that you agree with, and disdain the other.We are all human we want our way, we want to win, we want to survive.We would like to thrive.The answers to these problems lie beyond simple responses.Neither Liberal nor Consevative, or any other dichotomies.Not only Jews suffer.If you cut me do I not bleed, if you insult me am I not mad and indignant.You can hate Mel Gibson all you want, but I hate Joseph Lieberman.It goes on and on and Christian evangelistics in this country have a paradigm of all power to them and death to anyone else.Yes there are a lot of bad guys in this world, and anti semitism is one of them.If Jews don’t like people being prejudiced against them they should be more accepting of others.If Blacks don’t like “Racism” they should be more tolerant of Homosexuals.City people need to have a more open mind understanding country people.Blue collar people need to be more sympathetic to rich people[hard for me].In this experience of multiculturalism and tolerance and Democracy we are conhabitants with the Israelis, Arabs have no democracy and they are quite troublesome in Europe.American jews have been in the forefront of any philanthropic endeavor, and intellectual strategy in the world, inventors and thinkers,like einstein who declined the presidency of Yitzroel..Lets hope for a safer world for all.Yes this is a pipedream, we always have the, “Olom Ha Ba ” but a little happiness now,?Whats wrong with that? *

Gerry Garber says:

Patrick Prein says:
“Obviously Judaism has more veracity and established tyes with Western civilization than “Hamas”,we have known the Jews for much longer.But to say that the Media needs to always take the Jewish interpetation of History and existence at face value is preposterous.We know that many Arabs are extremist, so what, they are only speaking up for their side.”

This is ridiculous.

Of course Hamas and other Arabs antisemtic organization is “merely” talking up “their side.”

But their side is vile. They are Jew hater who want to see all Jews reduced to second class status or to be killed if they resist.

It sounds as if that is your side also.

Patrick–Have you taken your medication toady?

Sorry, but the quotation at the beginning of the Article is NOT from the Koran. It’s a fabricated Hadith frequently used by Hamas propaganda.

Barth, you are right that it is not in the Koran, but it is not a”fabricated Hadith” either. It is found in Bukhari, which is one of the canonical collections of Hadith. After the Koran, these collections are the most important docuements in Islam. Bukhari and its main counterpart Muslim, are like the Talmud for Jews.

Meylekh says:

Shim:
You’re right that it’s in the Hadith. However, several points. It’s important to make a distinction between the Koran and the Hadith. Even if the Hadith are important for Muslims, they don’t have the same authenticity as the Koran. Furthermore, Abu Huraira, who’s the transmitter of this Hadith is not universally accepted, e.g. he’s not accepted by Shias.
As you point out, the Hadith for the Muslims can be compared to the Talmud for the Jews. However, you wouldn’t want things pulled out of the Talmud without a global context, either!

Shena Rousselle says:

adorei isto hahahah

[url=http://calivit.com]calivita[/url]

I contain read your article. It’s seriously helpful. We could benefit considerably from it all. Fluent posting style together with vivid words make us all readers benefit from reading. I will probably share a person’s opinions along with my good friends.

Being creative is one word a large number of people are made aware of but are not able to fully grasp. Being creative is related to inspiration, fascination, innovation, unique, inventiveness, ingenuity, resourcefulness and so forth. Sad to say, many individuals will want to copy from some one than be creative.

Me love doing business with your corporation. Your net layout may be very easy to the eye. You have a very good great method to shop. I seriously enjoyed navigating in addition to ordering out of your site. It is rather, very in order to and user friendly. Great job with a fabulous web-site.

F*ckin’ amazing things here. I am very glad to see your post. Thanks a lot and i am looking forward to contact you. Will you please drop me a mail?

I’ve said that least 294546 times. The problem this like that is they are just too compilcated for the average bird, if you know what I mean

Wohh just what I was searching for, thanks for putting up.

whoah this blog is wonderful i love reading your articles. Keep up the good work! You know, many people are searching around for this info, you could help them greatly.

I have got read your own article. It’s genuinely helpful. We can certainly benefit considerably from it. Fluent publishing style and vivid thoughts make united states readers benefit from reading. I might share your current opinions along with my associates.

2000

Your comment may be no longer than 2,000 characters, approximately 400 words. HTML tags are not permitted, nor are more than two URLs per comment. We reserve the right to delete inappropriate comments.

Thank You!

Thank you for subscribing to the Tablet Magazine Daily Digest.
Please tell us about you.

Axis of Evil

A new book examines how the Nazis tailored their message for Arab and Muslim audiences

More on Tablet:

For These Moroccan Muslims, Mimouna Isn’t Just a Jewish Thing—It’s Their Heritage, Too

By Aomar Boum — Members of the Mimouna Club have made it their mission to learn about Jews and Jewish life as a way of learning about themselves