Your email is not valid
Recipient's email is not valid
Submit Close

Your email has been sent.

Click here to send another

On the Bookshelf

Polemics and pleas, productive and inflammatory: new books on Israel and Palestine

Print Email
I Shall Not Hate: A Gaza Doctor's Journey on the Road to Peace and Human Dignity

As Jeffrey Goldberg and Hussein Ibish’s op-ed, “Good News From the Middle East (Really),” argued last week, now’s no time to indulge in despair about Israel and Palestine. Conveniently for Jewish readers, then, two new books aim to give all of us a clearer understanding of who the Palestinians are by telling the stories of Sami al Jundi and Izzeldin Abuelaish, respectively, in The Hour of Sunlight: One Palestinian’s Journey From Prisoner to Peacemaker (Basic, February) and I Shall Not Hate: A Gaza Doctor’s Journey on the Road to Peace and Human Dignity (Walker, January). Both men have suffered at the hands of Israelis: Al Jundi, who was a young aspiring terrorist, spent 10 years in Israeli jails, while Abuelaish, a fertility doctor who has worked in Israeli hospitals, lost three daughters instantly when an Israeli shell hit his house in Gaza in early 2009. Yet rather than revel in the infinite bitterness and rancor exuded by so many small minds on both sides, both of these men express hopes for a peaceful compromise that will alleviate the suffering of Palestinians and offer security to Israelis.

***

Surveillance and Control in Israel/Palestine: Population, Territory and Power

Those less interested in personal histories—that is, policy wonks who don’t mind shelling out $140 for 392 pages of academic prose—can brush up on how and why Israel keeps track of Palestinians in Surveillance and Control in Israel/Palestine: Population, Territory and Power (Routledge, December). Co-edited by David Lyons, who directs the Surveillance Studies Centre at Queen’s University in Kingston, Ontario—an apt position, one might say, from which to watch over this burgeoning field—the book includes contributions from Israeli, Palestinian, and Canadian scholars on topics ranging from “colour-coded paperwork for Palestinian population control” to the “behavioral profiling in Israeli aviation security.”

***

The Goldstone Report

But, hey, if you want despair, you can certainly find plenty reason for it in books that rehash predictably nonproductive positions on the conflict. From Camp David to Cast Lead: Essays on Israel, Palestine, and the Future of the Peace Process (Lexington, February) offers up shocking news, such as: Avi Shlaim finds Ariel Sharon a bit too aggressive on the issue of the Palestinians! Nor should anyone be surprised by what they find in the new edition of The Goldstone Report (Nation, January) edited by Philip Weiss—unless, that is, they have thus far neglected to read Michelle Goldberg’s fascinating Tablet profile of the passionately anti-Zionist blog impresario.

***

The Jacqueline Rose Reader

Meanwhile, if you’d like to know how a literary scholar, trained in the analysis of verse, transforms herself into a noted anti-Zionist polemicist, The Jacqueline Rose Reader (Duke, February) walks you through the process. The collection includes Rose’s essays on Virginia Woolf and sundry psychoanalytic topics, an excerpt from her feminist sequel to Proust, and statements of her antipathy for Israeli policies (such as “Why Zionism Today Is the Real Enemy of the Jews”). For better or worse, Rose is the type of thinker who can acknowledge that academic boycotts of Israel have all sorts of problems—they’re “inconsistently and somewhat randomly applied,” and they shut down dialogue in precisely the situations in which open dialogue should be encouraged—but supports one anyhow, “on the grounds that, at the level of international politics, nothing is being done.”

***

Complete Modern Hebrew: A Teach Yourself Guide

One productive thing that both critics and supporters of Israel could spend more time doing: learning the languages spoken and written by Israelis and Palestinians. In the same way that it is generally accepted that it is necessary to speak Chinese to write with any authority about China, or French to write about France, one wishes more of the polemicists concerned about the Middle East would acknowledge that before they begin nattering on about solutions or abuses, they might want to study up. (Rose’s 2007 book on Zionism cites untranslated sources in French and German, but not, it seems, in Hebrew or Arabic.) The new edition of Sarah Nicholsen’s Complete Biblical Hebrew (McGraw-Hill, February) won’t help much, but Shula Gilboa’s Complete Modern Hebrew: A Teach Yourself Guide (McGraw-Hill, February) might. It seems, at least, that the book’s designers have been doing their best to learn a little more about Israel: While the 2004 edition had a cover image featuring that staple of the mostly non-Hebrew speaking Diaspora, the bagel, the new one features a somewhat more appropriate sivivon, which, while not particularly “modern,” at least generally displays four Hebrew characters.

Zubi!: The Real Hebrew You Were Never Taught in School

In fact, in studying the languages, one cannot help but appreciate the interdependence of Jews and Arabs in Israel. Especially if you pay attention to the slang terms cataloged by Danny Ben Israel in Zubi!: The Real Hebrew You Were Never Taught in School (Plume, February)—the subtitle of which suggests the book has set its sights pessimistically on the rather limited audience of ex-Hebrew day schoolers (who, honestly, have probably picked up at least the basic obscenities). Ben Israel justly acknowledges that “Israel owes a lot to multilayered, gloriously obscene Arabic curses” like kus ocht abuk ars, not to mention in-al abuk—and shouldn’t people who share the same ways of expressing fury and disgust be able to find some way to live in peace?

Print Email
gad horowitz says:

do you ever read any pro-israel books?

Raymond in DC says:

Tablet is yet another platform for “progressive” Jews – the sort who often tend to argue for the other side. So it shouldn’t surprise that their bookshelves are rich with books hostile to Israel. Let me suggest a few relevant books that are, if not pro-Israel, at least sympathetic to Israel:

“The Prime Ministers” by Yehuda Avner
“Palestine Betrayed” by Ephraim Karsh
“The Strong Horse” by Lee Smith
“A State Beyond The Pale” by Robbin Shepherd
“Army of Shadows” by Hillel Cohen
“The Other War” by Stephanie Gutmann
“The Fight for Jerusalem” by Dore Gold

I’m sure others can suggest similarly worthwhile books.

Alyssa says:

Ugh, that is some really foul Arabic swearing you put up. Basically translates to the c-word in English. Not what I’d call ‘glorious.’ Is that really necessary?

I’ve said that least 4004389 times. The problem this like that is they are just too compilcated for the average bird, if you know what I mean

Mortgages they can be handy http://freearticlesworld.com/?p=228343 trying to several times, at a remortgage and moreover locating a superior value, separate making use of several widening collateral in your residense to obtain balanced closed home finance loan, parenting money and merge main arrears yet undertaking anyone incessantly desired girl increases.

That is a fantastic indicate mention. Just publish.

2000

Your comment may be no longer than 2,000 characters, approximately 400 words. HTML tags are not permitted, nor are more than two URLs per comment. We reserve the right to delete inappropriate comments.

Thank You!

Thank you for subscribing to the Tablet Magazine Daily Digest.
Please tell us about you.

On the Bookshelf

Polemics and pleas, productive and inflammatory: new books on Israel and Palestine

More on Tablet:

Why Europe Has Trouble Fighting Anti-Semitism

By Eylon Aslan-Levy — Three reasons it has difficulty facing up to anti-Jewish hate