Your email is not valid
Recipient's email is not valid
Submit Close

Your email has been sent.

Click here to send another

Beggars on Horseback

The needy come to a New Jersey synagogue to claim their due, and the donations that result seem to flow both ways

Print Email
(Yivo)

In the evening shadows, an elderly man comes up the steps of the shul. “Ich bin a tateh fun nein kinder,” he says, meaning “I am a father of  nine children.” Ivrit, Yiddish?”  He asks me if I speak Hebrew or Yiddish. “Ivrit, Hebrew,” I answered, though I actually speak both. “I had a nituach”—surgery, in his words, a “hoperation,” he says in a breathy, winded Yiddish-ized English-Hebrew as though he had just run a half mile.

This man might have been my grandfather; his hands were parched like ears of corn, his nails yellowed most probably by psoriasis. I quarrel with myself: How much to give? $1? $5? A man looks like a walking heart attack, comes halfway around the world, and you give him $5? All I had were 20s. I hardened myself. “Do you have change?” I say. Of course he has change. He puts down his papers, a sheaf of papers he carries in a leather folder, like something from Bernard Malamud’s Magic Barrel. You could swear he smells of fish. Seeing his exertion, I told him to keep the $20 bill.

The motif of the beggar, both the holy and unholy ones, is firmly ensconced in Judaic lore, from the Talmud all the way through Hassidic tales. Begging intensified when we were forced to live in ghettos in Europe in the period following the Middle Ages. This continued in the shtetl. We were all one family then, staggered as we were by the waves of brutality visited on us by the gentile nations. This was the golden age of beggardom, which begat a new kind of beggar—the “schnorrer.” “Schnorrers” refer to those beggars who have an air of entitlement, as if they were exiled monarchs, gifts to civilization, who have the unfortunate position of having no money.

Every Tuesday morning at my synagogue, by the coffee urn just inside of the entrance, sit three elderly Russian men. They literally have their hands out. A dollar here and there, a few coins, a Yiddish turn of phrase, a mixture of gold tooth smiles and plaintive requests. One dollar buys you a torrent of blessings from them: A gut yahr, na zdrovie, they say. Spraznikom.

I love these men, with their blue-eyed, lined faces. Perhaps they are veterans of the Great War, remnants of the Red Army’s drive on Berlin. One of them is old enough for sure, but no one is quite sure why they are there.

And those are just the regulars. There are a host more who make cameo appearances, often from Israel. They make impassioned, sometimes anguished speeches beseeching donations for one important cause or another or for themselves. These men, anachronisms in human form—they would have been at home in the shtetl, with their dirty caftans, patched jackets, and stale cigarettes. Their faces, some of them, convey a world of dust and famine, feet in run-down boots that tread in gutters muddy with dirty snow and ice. These men (and they are almost always men) come in the modern equivalent of droshkies (Polish for horse-and-buggy taxis) beat-up car services and livery cabs.

Not too long ago, one young man from Israel asked me if he could take a few minutes to make a plea for funds during one morning minyan. I told him he could do so, after the aleinu. I knew this was after some of his customers would have already left, but the minyan was running late. It hurt me to say no, but I did.

He fumed. Afterward, I asked him how much money I caused him to lose—he told me $25. I gave it to him. He embraced me in gratitude, but I saw he wasn’t happy. Later someone pointed out to me that he may have “needed” to tell his story. I had robbed him of the opportunity to klop on the bimah and tell his tale. It wasn’t only the money. Without his speech he was painfully invisible.

One man I know appears at intervals and faithfully recites his tale with pathos, inveighing with all manner of fire and brimstone all that has befallen him. “I used to have parnassah, pay bills, have a business, but now …” His story is dear to him, so dear that in his mind it trumps davening. A tug-of-war develops between him and the shliach tzibbur, or leader of prayers, as to whose voice will triumph. “I have to make chasunahwedding—“now for three children …” is pitted against “Amen Y’hei Shmei Rabboh,” the climax of the Kaddish prayer. Some rush to shush him while others hear him out, pressing dollar bills and fives dramatically into his hands as he sings his song of sorrow. He can break your heart even if you think he is not telling the truth.

In my Passaic, N.J., synagogue, a benevolent attitude has formed toward worthy and non-worthy vagabonds alike. Everyone is given something and sometimes a little more than something. Not too long ago I struck up a deep conversation with Baruch. A man in his fifties, a seventh-generation Yerushalmi, Baruch took his tea with tons of sugar as we schmoozed. He had the visage of a holy man. He carried an album with him with photos of his parents and his children. Ten of them lived in a three-room apartment in the old city of Jerusalem. He was marrying off his third son, and he was begging and borrowing to do it. The man had such charm, had such Jew-holiness about him, I would have emptied my bank account into his, if I had anything.

Together we worked up a cozy steam. On his mother’s side, they came from the Carpathian Mountains of Galicia, where my ancestors are from. In his way, he was a devoted father and grandfather. He would provide by hook or by crook. I respected that. So what if his family was a lot larger than he could handle? Who hasn’t over-reached? Besides, there were already grandchildren. How could a Jewish child be a mistake? It was all very touching. Besides, he quoted from Talmud at a page a minute, and I matched him quote for quote. We had a jolly old time.

I can’t remember if this is actually so, but I believe he made himself as the Yiddish expression goes, ze’er ba’kvemt—very, or too comfortable. Perhaps he took out a cigarette and made smoke rings or maybe he downed a plate of cookies, I can’t remember exactly. He asked if I knew anyone who would be sympathetic to his plight. I actually did know someone, a wealthy hotelier who once told me that he wanted to “twin” his daughter’s wedding with a poor man’s wedding in Jerusalem. “Is he observant?” the Yerushalmi wanted to know. He was not observant, I told him.  With a horrified look, my Yerushalmi friend said that he could not take the money of someone who was not observant.

You had to admire him in a perverse way.  Here was a beggar and a chooser. At any rate, we both paid lip service to the coming of the Messiah, and I gave him $100. But after I did that, I asked him casually, if his children had any plans for making their way in life, like you know, working.

Without even a trace of irony he waved his hand and said, “Ze lo bishvilanu la’avod,” or “It is not for us to work.” At that point, I realized that we were both crazy—I for giving him money, and he for expecting me and the rest of the world to provide for all the children he sired pell-mell—without the slightest plan. We shared a bond as members of the same tribe, but our worldviews were wholly incommensurate with each other.

Nevertheless, somehow in the people’s yiddishkeit, in the precincts of the shul and the beis medrash—a world where virtue and piety rule the high seas of human thought and behavior, we are, all of us, as if in an opium den, rendered into holy fools.

Print Email
Hannah Lee says:

The Sages teach us that we have to first take care of our own (meaning the poor in our community) before others. Yes, my shul and my neighborhood are also popular with the meshulachim (shnorrers) from Israel and elsewhere, but we have to give judiciously. Do any one of us have unlimited funds for tzedakah?

ENeuer says:

Feuerman’s writing is such a joy to read not only because of his obvious literary gift but because it is twinned with an authenticity and deep love for klal yisroel that is brimming off the page.

Simcha Goldberg says:

You write beautifully. However, though I read it through twice or thrice, I do not understand your concluding paragraph. Please explain.

Ali P Joseph says:

This writer is really talented. I read his other piece last week about his father and this article is wonderful too.

Chananya R. says:

Wow R’ Yisrael – I really enjoyed reading this. Your writing style reads like poetry. B’yedidus. ~C

bfields says:

Wonderful turns of words… “painfully invisible,” and “holy fools.” I get it. Thank you for sharing your talent for connecting with others and setting your stories with context of our contemporary worlds.

Mildred Bilt says:

The professional beggar. They stand at the gates of cemetaries. They will pray over the deceased for you when you don’t have your own rabbi. In the old days before Israel paid to get them off the streets, each beggar had his own spot which was generational-literally passed down from generation to generation. They were a fixture all over Europe,as were other groups, but the Jews stayed in Jewish sections. It was a time honored profession before government welfare kicked in. Now they come from Israel in groups to synagogues to demand their due for Israel charities or whatever. Work or a trade is not a consideration-they are too busy studying and begging.Ben Gurion never envisaged that the custom would persist-he thought all the old ways would disappear with the creation of Israel. The notion could be applied to the entire spectrum of humankind.

Naomi says:

First “A Rabbi’s Christmas,” now this wonderful essay. Make Feuerman a regular Tablet contributor!

yehudah says:

i’m not sure if i’m glad those guys are still doing the same thing as ever, but i remember them well, and you depict it beautifully. should be ze’er ba’kvem (not bakvemt), by the way

Who says this guy doesn’t work. Raising a dozen children is work. I think these people’s role should be reframed. They are devoting themselves to Jewish survival to repopulating the world with Jews. That’s a job in my book even if he doesn’t punch a clock or have an IRA.

so beautiful thank you so much……

I reread this story. This isn’t just mildly offensive, it’s positively anti semitic. Let me quote.
“At that point, I realized that we were both crazy—I for giving him money, and he for expecting me and the rest of the world to provide for all the children he sired pell-mell—without the slightest plan.”
Mr. Feueruman this is an assualt on a core Orthodox belief . To describe those who believe that “every child carries his loaf of bread,” as irresponsible for this is what you’ve implied gives life to a vile stereotype. This is especially painful now now that the press image of ORthodox Jewry is at an all time low. From Tablet this doesn’t surprise me, but from you Mr. Feuerman it does.

Hershl says:

How I wish that all shuls would just bar these scum from plying their trade, and that is what it is, where others come to davven.

They are the epitome of some of the worst haredi traits; lying, schnorring, parasitism, stealing from the rest of us and from the tax payers and those who actually work.

They are now taking over Israel in their black hats and much of Brooklyn and NY state ( Monsey, Kiryat Yoel, and the other haredi pigsties that are rapidly springing up). They must be expunged like the cockroaches that invade our homes and never leave.

The haredim and these mooches refuse to work, abhor secular education, will not pay taxes if they can avoid it, hate Israel, refuse to serve in the military but want us to defend them, hate the secular who support them via our taxes.

We must refuse to give one cent to the haredim. The next time you see them schnorring, turn them out into the street.

Let them know that they are unwelcome.

Sanford Rosenblum says:

R’Yid: …suffused with wisdom, insight and love of Klal Yisroel..who are we to judge other Yidden, as expressed in some of the more pungent comments?..(signed)….Chananya’s Abba

2000

Your comment may be no longer than 2,000 characters, approximately 400 words. HTML tags are not permitted, nor are more than two URLs per comment. We reserve the right to delete inappropriate comments.

Thank You!

Thank you for subscribing to the Tablet Magazine Daily Digest.
Please tell us about you.

Beggars on Horseback

The needy come to a New Jersey synagogue to claim their due, and the donations that result seem to flow both ways

More on Tablet:

Meet Marc Weitzmann

By Isabel Fattal — The author of Tablet’s ‘France’s Toxic Hate’ series discusses his background