Your email is not valid
Recipient's email is not valid
Submit Close

Your email has been sent.

Click here to send another

Fighting Soccer’s Barbarians

My beloved Beitar Jerusalem has some racist fans. Instead of abandoning the team, we should take it back.

Print Email
Fans of the Beitar Jerusalem soccer team hold up a banner in Hebrew that reads “Beitar Pure Forever” during a match in Jerusalem on Jan. 26, 2012. (AFP/Getty Images)

This was more than Gaydamak was willing to take. Drawing on his extensive business connections in the former Soviet republics, he reached out to Ramzan Kadyrov, the president of Chechnya. Kadyrov is known both for his alleged involvement in human rights abuses and for his lavish lifestyle; in 2011, he celebrated his 35th birthday by flying in a bevy of Western celebrities, including action star Jean-Claude Van Damme and actress Hillary Swank. He is also the former president of Terek Grozny, the republic’s premiere soccer team. Gaydamak needed help: La Familia, he knew, would block any attempt to recruit an Israeli-Arab player, but a Chechen Muslim baller might pass, buying Beitar some desperately needed good will. Kadyrov’s proposed prospects were far from stellar, a 19-year-old defender with little experience, and a striker with a middling record. But if signed, they would set a precedent. Gaydamak returned from Grozny and announced the deal.

La Familia’s response was prompt. In last week’s game against Bnei Yehuda, the group took its usual place in the eastern terrace of Beitar’s stadium by giddily chanting, “We’re the country’s most racist team,” and then launched into a barrage of songs, most of which dealt with killing Arabs. As the match was reaching its peak, they unveiled an enormous homemade banner that read “Beitar will forever remain pure.” Their antics cost the team a $10,000 fine. In an effort to quell the conflict, Beitar’s coach, Eli Cohen, tried his hand at a bit of commentary. “We have no problem with Muslims,” he told the Israeli press. “We have a problem with Arabs. There’s a difference between a European Muslim and Muslims from the Middle East.” Needless to say, the statement did little to help the team appear more enlightened.

And while this week’s game against Umm al-Fahm, thanks mainly to massive security, proceeded without incident, some of Beitar’s most prominent fans, disgusted with La Familia’s antics, are publicly disavowing the team. Olmert, for example, wrote a widely discussed op-ed on Wednesday, announcing the he will no longer attend Beitar’s games until La Familia is stamped out. “If we do not remove these racists from our stadium and disconnect them from the team,” Olmert wrote, “we will be just like them. I will not be attending Beitar games until they are removed. I am sick and tired of being affiliated with the dark vulgarity of people who will never be a part of what Beitar is supposed to symbolize in sports and in Israeli society.”

I applaud Olmert’s sentiment but cannot bring myself to boycott Beitar. The thing is, I love that team, love it in an uncomplicated way, love it despite of its athletic shortcomings and its moral failings. I learned to love soccer on the eastern terrace, in the 1990s, and a big part of the attraction was the wild energy—then not nearly as odious as it is today—of the team’s most dedicated fans. And being a fan of Beitar also taught me that Frank Foer was right when he observed soccer’s canny capacity to preserve and cultivate nationalist pride while reining in actual tribal violence. As much as the goons of La Familia are injurious to my sensibilities, I am relieved to see that beyond the sporadic outburst here and there, the group has failed to join forces with any of the like-minded—and truly violent—radical right-wing organizations working in Israel today, such as the Kach movement or fringe settler groups like the hilltop youth. Instead, La Familia invests all of its considerable resources—manpower, cash, enthusiasm—in Beitar. And while their behavior is offensive, it is, taken in perspective, without much consequence.

Rather than abandon the team and leave it with few fans but the fanatics, I hope to see more diehard Beitar followers pack its stadium and counter La Familia’s viciousness with humor and creativity. For every violent call to genocide they compose, let’s write wittier, peaceful ditties. True, there’s not much that rhymes with “Muslim” or with “Chechnya,” but we shall overcome. And rather than exhaust itself in endless war against La Familia, Beitar should find better ways to attract new fans. It should not focus on what it’s not—not racist, not hateful, not violent—but on what it is. And what it is, what it has always been, and what I deeply believe it will always remain, is a fine, fine soccer team.

***

Like this article? Sign up for our Daily Digest to get Tablet Magazine’s new content in your inbox each morning.

1 2View as single page
Print Email
Poupic says:

This is true the chants are racists but they are only chants so far. On the other hand Molotov cocktails on Jews do not get the accusation of racism from you. Why is that?

Hugh J says:

“Sporadically, more overtly racist statements, like “death to the Arabs,” would be made.”

First, I think sporting events should be free of extreme rhetoric and fan bashing pertaining to the personal attributes of others….

Having said that, when did ‘Arab’ or ‘Muslim’ become a race? One is a demographically assigned status and the other is a religion.

I know the word is thrown around so that the person using it is taken more seriously than they otherwise would be, but the serious nature of true racism becomes diminished when the word is carelessly tossed into every situation we don’t like.

for goodness’ sake – it’s only 22 idiots kicking a leather ball up and down a field!

sidney51 says:

You can employ sophistry all you wish in order to rationalize your continued support of this team. As an Israeli, I say that anyone who supports Beitar is the equivalent of those persons in 20th century United States who elected not to oppose the Ku Klux Klan. How can any decent Israeli be associated with this team? The management has effectively given veto power to the ugliest element of Israeli society. And what of the terror at Malcha? I was there the next day. The Arabs feared for their lives. Beitar is the scum of Israel. For shame.

So if it’s ok for them to shout “Death to Arabs” you wouldn’t mind if they shouted “Death to Jews” then? It’s just a game after all, right? A bit of chanting never hurt anyone…

Yeah, I didn’t think so.

Howard E Davis says:

As a jew living in America I had never heard of this situation vis a vis “barbaric” soccer fans but I am sorry to read about the depths of ignorance and hatred that my fellow jews are capable of. I understand that feelings “run deep” in Israel and it is all too easy to see “others” as the enemy but I’m inclined to support the view expressed by “sidney51″.

Pip Power says:

“La Famiglia is currently 5,500 fans strong—the group became a de facto lobby and quickly began intervening in the team’s decision-making process”.

ANOTHER JEWISH LOBBY!

Now you can see first hand how Jewish lobbies work!

They destroy everything that’s fair & decent & demand their own selfish ways!

Any criticism of La Famiglia will be deemed as ANTISEMITISM. lol

Pip Power says:

The Ku Kluk Klan was ALWAYS controlled by Jews!

They used reverse psychology! They got brainless thugs to break tombstones or paint the door of synagogues, whenever Israel was being criticized by the media. That way they stopped the negative criticism & allowed Israel off the hook.

Israel has got to be the only country in the world where racist sports fans get international coverage, right?

Rich Ross says:

“We have a problem with Arabs. There’s a
difference between a European Muslim and Muslims from the Middle East.”
Needless to say, the statement did little to help the team appear more
enlightened”

Needless to say,only the most delusional of(take your pick)Liberals, Progressives, Leftists can fail to understand the implicit truth contained in Coach Cohen’s statement.

PhillipNagle says:

Among sport fans, soccer fans are alone in their violence and stupidity, It amazes me how a sport so dull can arouse such passions.

What are you talking about? Beitar fans ran riot through Malcha mall last year attacking Arab citizens at work or shopping. They beat up completely innocent people in brutal gangs. They also ran riot in Netanya.

There is no implicit truth at all. Cohen is ignorant. Arab Muslims play in almost all Israeli club teams and have played for the Israeli national team as well – starting with Jimmy Turk an Arab from Yaffo and dozens since then. Cohen is basically lying flat out and he knows it.

Poupic says:

Read again what I wrote. Arabs throw Molotov cocktails on Jews. Was there a time that they were called racists too?

Pip Power says:

Allah is the greatest.

He who thanks Allah will be rewarded.Oh Allah, loosen your power and strength on the Jews. (Amen.)Please Allah, kill them all…And don’t leave any of them alive. (Amen.)Oh Allah, with your great power. Allah!We are asking you with your infinite power, dear Allah. Allah!Please dear Allah, take revenge for our martyrs’ blood. Allah!Please Allah, get rid of the Jews.Bring them down.They are not as powerful as you.Please Allah, make the earth shake and destroy the pillars of their civilisation.Please Allah, cast fear and terror into their hearts.Oh Allah disperse them so they become lost once again.Oh Allah, show us a sign.Oh Allah, surprise them in a way they don’t expect.Oh Allah, cast fear and terror into their hearts.

THIS IS WHAT MUSLIM PALESTINIANS ARE PRAYING EVERY DAY!

Pip Power says:

THERE ARE NO INNOCENT ARAB MOHAMMEDANS

Islam’s Ancient Hatred For The Jews

While Islam envisions the day when Christians and Jews will convert to Islam en masse, there is a distinction within Islam’s end time narrative between the final destiny of Christians and that of the Jews. In Islam’s version of the last-days, we see that all Christians will either accept Islam or be killed. Certainly, when we look at this final picture, it is impossible to say that Islam has any real affinity for Christians or Christianity. But when analyzing Islamic teaching and traditions about the Jews, one gets a very cold feeling that the only destiny that Islam has marked out for the Jews is that of an absolute and total slaughter. We see in the Islamic traditions a dark and very persistent hatred for the Jews nearly identical to the ideology expressed through Nazism. This ideology of hatred is fully supported and nurtured throughout the Quran and the Islamic traditions. For instance, speaking of Jews, the Quran says:

Amongst them we (Allah) have placed enmity and hatred till the Day of Judgment. Every time they kindle the fire of war, Allah doth extinguish it; but they (ever) strive to do mischief on earth. And Allah loveth not those who do mischief. -Surah 5:64 (Yusuf Ali)

Pip Power says:

THEY DON’T HAVE TO SHOUT “DEATH TO THE JEWS”, THEIR PROPHET MOHAMMED SHOUTED THAT 1400 YEARS AGO & ALL HIS FOLLOWERS HAVE TO DO IS QUOTE QURAN OR HADITH!

ITS PART OF THEIR RELIGION!

Pip Power says:

MOHAMMED SAID JEWS WERE APES & PIGS

Amongst them we (Allah) have placed enmity and hatred till the Day of Judgment. Every time they kindle the fire of war, Allah doth extinguish it; but they (ever) strive to do mischief on earth. And Allah loveth not those who do mischief. -Surah 5:64 (Yusuf Ali)

This verse makes it clear that there will be “enmity and hatred” against the Jews until the very end of the present age. So much for those who claim that the Quran’s scorn for Jews is limited only to specific historical incidences in Muhammad’s career. Not only does the Quran portray Jews as those who start wars and cause general mischief in the earth, but it also literally claims that Allah was so disgusted by the Jews, that he cursed them and literally transformed many of them into “apes and swine,” assigning them the lowest “rank” among humankind:

When in their insolence they transgressed (all) prohibitions, We said to them: “Be ye apes, despised and rejected.” -Surah 7:166 (Yususf Ali)

Those who incurred the curse of Allah and His wrath, those of whom some He transformed into apes and swine, those who worshipped evil;- these are (many times) worse in rank, and far more astray from the even path! -Surah 5:60 (Yusuf Ali)

And well ye knew those amongst you who transgressed in the matter of the Sabbath: We said to them: “Be ye apes, despised and rejected.” -Surah 2:65 (Yusuf Ali)

Among the more anti-Semitic and vocal Muslims, these verses have become absolute favorites. Walid Shoebat is a former Muslim who grew up in the Palestinian territories. Recalling being taken on a school trip to the Jerusalem zoo as a child, Walid relates, “The Islamic teacher would tell us, ‘this gorilla was originally a Jew.’ I look at this now and I think, this is what Naziism teaches – in its worst form. This is being taught throughout the entire Middle East.”1 Just as the Nazis declared that Jews were subhuman “vermin” in order to justify their inhumane treatment of the Jews, so has the Muslim world followed the lead of the Quran in dehumanizing the Jewish race.

I wouldn’t allow my dog play with a Mohammedan!

Pip Power says:

WHEN THESE MOHAMMEDANS GET CONTROL, IT WILL BE YOUR HEAD THAT THEY WILL USE AS A BALL!

THEY DID IT BEFORE!

this is upsetting on so many levels. “we have no problem with muslims. we have a problem with arabs” sounds like the “i don’t have a problem with jews- only zionists” garbage we deal with regularly. it is exactly the same and equally wrong. to support this team is to support bigotry and hatred. since fines do nothing to address the problem- perhaps banning beitar from competing would help?

Hugh J says:

“Please Allah, kill them all…And don’t leave any of them alive.”

Uhhh…that’s redundant. ESL classes not going so well?

It is refreshing to see the rare case when a Jewish person criticizes expressions of racism and other forms of bigotry from other Jews. In fact, I should take a picture. CLICK.

Pip Power says:

THIS IS WHAT MUSLIM PALESTINIANS ARE PRAYING EVERY DAY!

MUSLIMS’ DESTINY IS TO KILL JEWS

Last week, the principal Palestinian Authority religious leader, the Mufti Muhammad Hussein, presented the killing of Jews by Muslims as a religious Islamic goal. At an event celebrating the 47th anniversary of the founding of Fatah, he cited the Hadith(Islamic tradition attributed to Muhammad) saying that the Hour of Resurrection will not come until Muslims fight the Jews and kill them:

“The Hour [of Resurrection] will not come until you fight the Jews.

The Jew will hide behind stones or trees.

Then the stones or trees will call:

‘Oh Muslim, servant of Allah, there is a Jew behind me, come and kill
him.’”
Palestinian Media Watch reported regularly during the PA
terror campaign (Intifada, 2000-2005) on the repeated use of this Hadith by PA clerics on official PA TV to motivate Palestinians to terror attacks, preaching that Muslims had anIslamic obligation to kill Jews. The fact that the Mufti quotes this now indicates that this may have remained part of the PA’s religious establishment’s teachings, even though it is less frequently promoted on PA TV.

The last time official PA TV broadcast a sermon during which this Hadith calling to kill Jews was quoted was in 2010.

The years of PA promotion of killing Jews and PA religious leaders’ citing thisHadith to justify it, may have contributed to the high
acceptance of it in PA society. A poll sponsored by the Israel Project last year found that 73% of Palestinians “believe” this Hadith. [July 2011, Greenberg Quinlan Rosner.]

The moderator who introduced the Mufti at the Fatah event last week reiterated another Islamic belief; that the Jews are the descendants of apes and pigs:

“Our war with the descendants of the apes and pigs (i.e., Jews) is a
war of religion and faith.”

The Mufti did not distance himself from this hate statement that Islam is in a religious war with the Jews, but added to it that Islam’s
goal is to kill Jews.

There are numerous collections of Hadith, some of which are
not accepted as reliable. However, the Mufti stressed that the Islamic belief that Jews will be killed by Muslims as a precursor to Resurrection, is an authentic Islamic belief because it appears in “the reliable” and trusted Hadith collections of Al-Bukhari and Muslim.

This Islamic tradition asserts that as the killing of Jews will progress, Jews will hide behind stones and trees, but even they will expose the Jews and call out:

“Oh Muslim, servant of Allah, there is a Jew behind me, come and kill him.”

One tree however, called the Gharqad, will hide the Jews from
the Muslims. The Mufti in his talk at the Fatah event claimed that in response to this Islamic belief, Israelis have been planting Gharqad trees around their cities and towns, in order to have a place to hide from the Muslims who will be coming to kill them.

This is not the first time the Mufti has incited to hatred against Jews in the name of Islam. In a sermon at the Al-Aqsa Mosque in 2010,
he preached that the Jews are the “enemies of Allah.”

The Mufti is appointed by PA Chairman Mahmoud Abbas. He voiced
this latest hate speech, that Jews are to be killed by Muslims, at an official Fatah celebration. Abbas is also the Chairman of Fatah.

The following is an excerpt from the Fatah ceremony broadcast on PA TV:

Moderator at Fatah ceremony:

“Our war with the descendants of the apes and pigs (i.e., Jews) is a
war of religion and faith.

Long Live Fatah! [I invite you,] our honorable Sheikh.”

PA Mufti Muhammad Hussein comes to the podium and says:

“47 years ago the [Fatah] revolution started. Which revolution? The
modern revolution of the Palestinian people’s history. In fact, Palestine in its entirety is a revolution, since [Caliph] Umar came [to conquer Jerusalem, 637 CE], and continuing today, and until the End of Days. The reliable Hadith (tradition attributed to Muhammad), [found] in the two reliable collections, Bukhari and Muslim, says:

“The Hour [of Resurrection] will not come until you fight the Jews.

The Jew will hide behind stones or trees.

Then the stones or trees will call:

‘Oh Muslim, servant of Allah, there is a Jew behind me, come and kill
him.’

Except the Gharqad tree [which will keep silent].”

Therefore it is no wonder that you see Gharqad [trees]

surrounding the [Israeli] settlements and colonies..”

Hugh J says:

So…what exactly is it you’re trying to say?

Actually, no, the KKK was NOT controlled by Jews.

Right… And Torah says to slaughter non-Jews.

Oops, you’ve gotten your definitions muddled.

2000

Your comment may be no longer than 2,000 characters, approximately 400 words. HTML tags are not permitted, nor are more than two URLs per comment. We reserve the right to delete inappropriate comments.

Thank You!

Thank you for subscribing to the Tablet Magazine Daily Digest.
Please tell us about you.

Fighting Soccer’s Barbarians

My beloved Beitar Jerusalem has some racist fans. Instead of abandoning the team, we should take it back.

More on Tablet:

The Most Important Thing Netanyahu Did in New York Wasn’t at the U.N.

By Yair Rosenberg — It was meeting Indian Prime Minister Narendra Modi