Your email is not valid
Recipient's email is not valid
Submit Close

Your email has been sent.

Click here to send another

Israel at the Ends of the Earth

Why do island nations like Palau and Nauru vote with Israel at the U.N.? Israeli aid has something to do with it.

Print Email
Leliana Firisua, honorary consul of Israel in the Solomon Islands (in blue), at the headquarters of an Israeli-friendly road construction company in the capital, Honiara. (Matthew Fishbane)
Related Content

My Hunt for Solomon’s Temple

The Internet says the ruins of the First Temple are in the South Pacific. Matthew Fishbane went to find them.

Last November, when the United Nations General Assembly voted on whether to recognize Palestine as a state, only nine nations in the body of 193 voted “no” with Israel. Among them: Micronesia (Jewish population: zero), the Marshall Islands (ditto), Palau (same), and Nauru (total population of 10,000, less than the annual AIPAC conference). These Pacific Island nations almost always line up behind Israel when the U.N. votes on resolutions concerning the Jewish state.

Are Palau and the Marshall Islands packed with Judeophiles? Or is there another reason for this political support?

Those first three nations are all in what’s called “free association” with the United States—a compact that means they receive financial assistance in exchange for voting with the United States. But Micronesia, the Marshall Islands, Palau, Nauru, and the Solomon Islands also enjoy generous Israeli aid from the government and from NGOs based on the belief that development is a way to cultivate rare votes of support for Israel in international forums. (For a fascinating, in-depth look into how this project works in the Solomon Islands, see here.)

The story of Israel’s development diplomacy begins in 1958, when the government of Israel established a foreign-aid department called Mashav, the Center for International Development and Cooperation, run out of its foreign ministry. In the years since, Mashav has made a name for itself by funding or partnering on agriculture, water, and clean-energy projects in far-flung countries. The organization sends Israeli advisers abroad to consult on these projects, and it offers scholarships for training programs offered in Israel. Ilan Fluss, a spokesman for Mashav, told me it was founded both to offer vital help and also, explicitly, as a way of garnering support for Israel in international forums.

Though Israel remains isolated in the international arena, other things have changed a lot since the late 1950s. Israel joined the OECD in 2010, and its GDP last year was about $251 billion. Today, Israel’s combined contributions to Mashav, the World Bank, and other major foreign assistance total $140 million, Fluss said, adding that Mashav’s budget was “a small part” of that sum, although he declined to offer specifics. (Israel’s aid is about .07 percent of its gross national income, a small percentage compared to U.S. foreign aid, which totals .21 percent, and that of Switzerland, whose aid amounts to .41, according to data published by The Guardian.) Still, through Mashav, the Israeli government is currently overseeing projects in 98 countries, from model dairy farms in China to early-childhood education programs in Ghana.

But for all the good the Israeli government does through its foreign aid projects, British Orthodox Rabbi Yossi Ives believes that it’s far under Israel’s potential. Seven years ago, as a religious leader in England, he said he could see Jewish values of helping the poor in action in Israel and Great Britain, yet there was little happening in the developing world. “It became increasingly clear to me that by comparison with what could be done, so very little was actually happening,” he said. “Most of what Israelis know about is immediate disaster relief, like after an earthquake. But when there is no disaster, or a silent disaster like the problems of healthcare, malnourishment, economic deprivation, where Israel can make a difference, it became clear to me that there’s a huge potential.”

The answer, Ives thought, was to start an organization to send Israeli experts—like architects, water specialists, and agronomists—to third-world countries in dire need. So, three years ago he founded Tag International Development, an acronym for the Hebrew words Torah and Gdulah (meaning worldly greatness) with the goal of expanding the reach of Israeli aid abroad. Whereas Mashav is a government agency working with other national governments and at the U.N., Tag is focused more on local organizations in the recipient countries.

Mashav’s Fluss said that the government chooses its target countries based on a mix of need along with Israel’s political aims—from building ties with growing economies to securing votes at the U.N. “We do not decide on doing development activities only by the voting, it’s not a measurement for doing development,” Fluss said. “But the Pacific Islands are countries with great need, and development actions there have proven themselves to be effective in voting in the U.N.” Fluss added that development work has helped Israel form working alliances with other countries as a breather from questions about its policies toward the Palestinians. Tag, on the other hand, focuses on countries that need help and that have solid partner organization on the ground, Chief Operations Officer Amos Avgar told me. “Our agenda is not political,” Avgar said. “It’s humanitarian, although we do want to position Israel in a better light.”

In its first year, 2010, Tag worked on an emergency-preparedness plan in Indonesia, along with other projects in Georgia and Azerbaijan. For one project, an Israeli architect flew to Sri Lanka to help redesign a farming training center. For another, Tag is helping to build a beekeeping program in Burma. The organization’s budget is about $1 million, Ives said, and though most funding comes from private donors, Tag cooperates with Mashav on projects in the Solomon Islands, Sri Lanka, Indonesia, and Burma. Other partners range from Google to the United Nations Development Program to the Israeli drip-irrigation company Netafim and the Joint Distribution Committee. Tag also works with a host of local organizations in Georgia, Indonesia, the Maldives, Jordan, and Thailand, among others.

Ives said he and other Tag staff do not hide their backgrounds. But Tag is registered in the United Kingdom and the United States, not Israel. And the logo includes two Hebrew letters, but they are barely visible, tucked away inside much larger English letters. Yet Ives wears a thick black beard and his kippah no matter where he travels and told me, via Skype from Indonesia, that he relishes being the face of the Jewish people in the countries where he operates, especially in Muslim countries like Jordan, Turkey, or Indonesia.

“For many of our partners, their relationship with Tag and its Israeli partners is their only contact with Israel,” said Ives, who does not hold Israeli citizenship. “At Tag, we believe this is inherently valuable.” Asked whether Israel’s development is possibly used as a fig leaf for its policies at home, Ives bristled. “Should Israeli specialists not go to help people trapped in rubble in Haiti because there are problems still unresolved in their country?” he asked.

One of Ives’ first consultants was American-born Israeli Yoel Siegel, 62, who works as a consultant on development for the Israeli government and various nonprofits. Siegel was running a training seminar in Israel for Mashav when a student from the Solomon Islands, studying in Israel thanks to Israeli government funding, asked Siegel to help his province form a development plan. Siegel flew over, funded by both Tag and Mashav. He has since been there four more times—which he said is exceptional for Israeli work abroad.

One of the peculiarities of working on aid projects as an Israeli is the reaction of evangelical Christians, Siegel said. “I have people come up and touch me just because I come from the Holy Land,” he said of his time in the Solomon Islands. “I have to be careful not to be viewed in any Messianic ways.” That precaution aside, Siegel told me he thinks Israel’s history makes it an ideal partner for development. “If you look at Israel in 1950 and you look at it today, the change, it’s unbelievable,” Siegel said. “And we still have some of that old developing country mentality. We go out, we sit in the villages, we sit in local coffee shops and local restaurants, we eat local food, and we get our hands dirty. That’s very Israeli, this informality.”

***

Like this article? Sign up for our Daily Digest to get Tablet Magazine’s new content in your inbox each morning.

Print Email
Guest says:

Has Israeli aid to Haiti and other ravaged zones had an impact?

Jacob Arnon says:

I think they have had an impact. otherwise it would be hard to explain why some Muslim countries attacked Israel wit the usual lies.

John Salisbury says:

Laughable considering Israel itself gets 3billion in aid from Uncle Sam each year

yeah, mostly in the form of subsidies to US arms manufacturers. Don’t worry, little of it leaves the US.

John Salisbury says:

Israel can spend it how they like.It is embarrassing, considering Israel has a GDP of some 240 billion,and their aid is exempt from Congressional budget cuts.

Reptilian2012 says:

Israel doesn’t need “a breather from questions about its policies toward the Palestinians”, she has facts on her side!

In the words of the late, great Joseph Heller (author of “Catch-22″): “When the Middle East explodes, the US will need a place to tie up their boats and get their soldiers laid.” Israel remains our most reliable ally in the Middle East. They are also a testing ground for most weapons in the American arsenal.

Yechiel Gordon says:

Yes, Israel’s aid to the terrorist Duvalier regime had the impact of making Israel

hated by the Haitians, just as Israeli military aid to the neo-Nazi regime of Argentina made Israel hated in Argentina, as Israeli aid to El Salvadoran death squads (Galil assault rifles being their weapon of choice) made Israel hated in El Salvador, as Israeli aid military aid to Indonesia that led to the deaths of 250,000 civilians made Israel hated in Indonesia.

John Salisbury says:

Joseph Heller.Ethnic background?

CygnusA81 says:

Funny, morons like yourself never complain that Egypt gets a $1 billion plus a year from the US. Or Pakistan for that matter. Nope, your hard-on obsession is only for Israel.

Israel’s aid to the Guatemalan genocide in the 1980s is well-known, and well-documented. There is no country in the world that actually supports Israel, save its imperial sponsors. Israel’s direct economic and military relations with Apartheid South Africa are also legion, and since the end of legal apartheid, the South Africans have spoken quite aggressively about the matter of Zionism.

People know. Maybe US Zionists like to pretend that Netanyahu isn’t a pompous, belligerent racist — but the guy runs his mouth. As does the (Russian) Foreign Minister, a fascist of the first degree.

Africa, Asia, Latin America — and increasingly in Europe and the United States, there is tremendous fatigue with a race-state that is always at war, expansionist and definitionally racist.

Jews live in Europe, Latin America and the US without sanction or persecution. There is no danger to Jewish communities in Europe or the Americas — and it is the formation of the Zionist state that led directly and immediately to the destruction of long-standing Jewish communities in the Arab world.

The sooner Zionism is dispensed with and every person of the region has a right to citizenship in secular and democratic state, the happier everyone will be.

Apartheid isn’t worth a single life. It’s not justifiable. It is a crime.

John Salisbury says:

Only a third of the amount that Israel gets? A poor country with a huge population….

CygnusA81 says:

Israel, gets the money because of the treaty it signed with Egypt. Second, why should Israel apologize for becoming successful.

John Salisbury says:

I thought it was the other way around.
Sure Israel is successful so maybe they don’t need American welfare any more.

I’m pro-Israel, but I agree. Cynics see Israel as a patsy for the USA. Israel has a stable economy and it should slowly get rid of US aid. That being said, Israel provides utilities for free to gaza and the west bank, and that probably does put a strain on its financial resources somewhat. It’s a complicated issue.

So you think Israel deliberately supports genocidal regimes?

What we have to consider is that the truth is murkier than either side makes it seem. Israel has made questionable choices, but so have many other states. The question we must always ask is why is Israel being put in the spotlight when there are far worse atrocities going on elsewhere, with much clearer good/bad sides. Why is the spotlight always on Israel. What is it that makes Israel want to be persecuted?

Yep, he was a member of the tribe. I think the Israelis were a useful ally for the US in the Cold War, but the Cold War is over and have now become a net liability to the US from a strict Realpolitik perspective.

There are shared values, etc., but international affairs are always largely driven by self-interest, and I suspect this is why the USA is gradually turning against Israel. That and American Jews not pumping out enough kids ;)

I also wonder how much being whiter than the Palestinians after all those years in Europe helps them with the GOP, even though nobody will admit it ;)

Pity all the facts are against her!

Wow – a reptile defending Israel! A match made in hell!

So Israel is there basically so that US soldiers can fish for crabs and/or get crabs from prostitutes?

Egypt and Pakistan are of ACTUAL strategic importance. Israel is there only for US soldiers to crab fish and/or getting crabs from sex workers!

LOL. Cut off the aid and then see how ‘successful’ Israel REALLY is …

And all this time I thought that the US was the patsy! And by ‘utilities’ do you mean tear gas, baton charges and cluster bombs?

Yes it has – thanks to Israel, organ trafficking has increased 500 percent in Haiti! Come visit an Israeli relief camp and leave minus a kidney!

Because nobody likes your rich, white hypocritical @sses?

Reptilian2012 says:

Somewhat? You must be joking. Utility rates increased by 200 percent in the last two years.

Yes – bribing people always does – isn’t that how all those US senators keep voting for Israel all the time?

Reptilian2012 says:

What atrocities, the complex heart surgery Ismail Ganiyeh’s brother got for free in an Israeli hospital a few months ago? Treating him was indeed a crime against humanity!

CygnusA81 says:

Wow Jay, thanks for fever swamp view.

Hummus from Egypt doesn’t count as a strategic importance you know.

Neither does Pakistan’s…I don’t know, Taliban export?

Cut off aid to your two precious countries and they would implode.

Cut off ‘aid’ to Israel which 90% goes back to the US would only hurt high-tech, US jobs. But since you are a moron you would probably like that.

CygnusA81 says:

It’s tied to the Israel/Eygpt treaty. You should read up on history before you mouth off.

lumiss says:

This is really quite amazing. How sick must you be to put forward such allegations. You poor lost thing. Shame on you.

Yechiel Gordon says:

Though published some time ago, the book Who Israel Arms and Why does a good job of laying out the financial and military rationales for Israel’s support of mass murderers.

Examples from Iran, Asia, Central America and Africa: The Shah of Iran (thousands killed or tortured), Suharto (250,000 killed), the death squads of Nicaragua (50,000 killed with Galil assault rifles in two weeks) Joseph Savimbi (500,000 to 1000,000 killed) and Idi Amin (roughly 1,000,000 killed).

I remember being shocked and in disbelief when I first read the book. Fact checks have shown the documentation to be essentially accurate, sad to say.

Yechiel Gordon says:

That’s easy:

A) As Americans, we are paying taxes that go to support Israeli
atrocities.

B) As Jews, Israel claims to be acting in our name.

2000

Your comment may be no longer than 2,000 characters, approximately 400 words. HTML tags are not permitted, nor are more than two URLs per comment. We reserve the right to delete inappropriate comments.

Thank You!

Thank you for subscribing to the Tablet Magazine Daily Digest.
Please tell us about you.

Israel at the Ends of the Earth

Why do island nations like Palau and Nauru vote with Israel at the U.N.? Israeli aid has something to do with it.

More on Tablet:

The Jew Who Turned the Left Against Israel

By Joshua Muravchik — A new book shows how Austrian Chancellor Bruno Kreisky was the ancestor of the Jews who now serve in the hate-Israel movement