Your email is not valid
Recipient's email is not valid
Submit Close

Your email has been sent.

Click here to send another

Satellite of Hate

In Kyrgyzstan, anti-Semitism erupts in the wake of the president’s ouster

Print Email
A Kyrgyz opposition supporter waves the national flag near the main government building during an anti-government protest in Bishkek on April 7, 2010. (Vyacheslav Oseledko/AFP/Getty Images)

When protestors in the Kyrgyz capital of Bishkek violently seized the executive office building and evicted its occupant, President Kurmanbek Bakiyev, on April 7, they draped the massive, Soviet-era structure in signs befitting their revolutionary fervor. Opposition to Bakiyev’s corrupt and increasingly oppressive regime had been simmering for years in this central Asian nation and reached a boiling point in early April when Russia increased duties on gas and diesel exports. Bakiyev had visibly enriched himself and his family since taking office in 2005 after leading the country’s “Tulip Revolution,” one of the lesser-known “color revolutions,” in which popular movements peacefully ousted pro-Russian regimes in former Soviet republics. Judging from the posters draping the White House—as the executive office building is known—the anger at Bakiyev was white hot. “The Bitch Bakiyev, Get Out,” was a particularly popular motto that I saw spray-painted in several different locations. After decamping to his native village in the southern part of the country, Bakiyev fled to Kazakhstan a week after his downfall and is now residing in Belarus at the behest of its authoritarian leader, Alexander Lukashenko.

Alongside the anti-Bakiyev scrawlings, another slogan seemed oddly out of place: “Kyrgyzstan has no place for dirty Jews and the likes of Maxim.” This imprecation was directed at Maxim Bakiyev, the erstwhile president’s youngest son. In November of last year, the then-president of Kyrgyzstan appointed Maxim to head the Central Agency for Development, Investment, and Innovation, a body that was supposed run the country’s lagging, agriculturally based economy. The call for Jews to leave the country hanging on the gate outside the White House was a reference to Eugene Gourevitch, a shadowy, Kyrgyz-born businessman with American citizenship who was rumored to be a close associate of Maxim’s.

Attacks on the country’s small Jewish community—which numbers no more than 2,000, down from 40,000 at the end of World War II—did not end there. On the evening of April 8, a small group of vandals launched a Molotov cocktail into the courtyard of Bishkek’s synagogue. Fortunately there was no damage, and the house of worship’s neighbors—gentiles, as the head of Kyrgyzstan’s Jewish community, Rabbi Arieh Reichman, was sure to tell me—prevented a fire from breaking out. While the traumatic political events in Kyrgyzstan have shaken the entire country, they have especially affected its Jewish community, which throughout its two millennia of history has never experienced the pogroms or violent harassment that have scarred the Jewish Diaspora. (Soon after it gained independence from the Soviet Union, Kyrgyzstan established diplomatic relations with Israel, and relations between the two countries have generally been warm.)

It is perhaps because of this lack of knowledge about and experience with Jews that Eugene Gourevitch makes such an easy hate figure in a moderate-Muslim country whose leaders have had a hand in the till. Gourevitch, who was born in Kyrgyzstan, acquired American citizenship in 1990. In July of 2008, he founded the financial services firm MGN Capital, which enjoyed a consultative role with the government agency operated by Maxim Bakiyev, as well as in the privatization of the country’s electric and telecommunications utilities. MGN grew to have around 50 employees by the time of last month’s tumult and “became very successful in just a year,” one former employee told me last month in Bishkek. Though Gourevitch denied having any ties to Maxim Bakiyev, MGN’s nickname in Kyrgyzstan was “Maxim, Gourevitch, Nadel,” (this last being for Mikhail Nadel, a business associate of Gourevitch’s). Following Bakiyev’s downfall, according to him and several of his erstwhile colleagues, the company is now in utter disarray.

On March 9, less than a month before Bakiyev would be swept from office, Gourevitch was indicted, along with 55 other co-conspirators, in an Italian court for defrauding a telecommunications company of $2.7 billion. According to the 1,600 page arrest warrant, Gourevitch “created, managed and used a series of companies through which he moved an enormous quantity of money constituting the ‘cuts’ destined for the various members of the conspiracy.” The next day, he resigned as head of MGN, citing “personal problems,” in the words of a former employee. In the weeks leading up to Bakiyev’s April 7 ouster, what remained of Kyrgyzstan’s independent press reported on the alleged ties between Gourevitch and Maxim, adding yet another layer to the well-developed narrative of the president’s corrupt family. One newspaper featured a cartoon depicting Gourevitch pushing around various members of the Bakiyev regime in a baby stroller.

According to former employees, Gourevitch began traveling with two or three bodyguards earlier this year, and juggled four cell phones. He was rumored to live next door to the prime minister in Bishkek’s toniest neighborhood. Russian television, one of Gourevitch’s former workers told me, “portrayed him like a warlord,” criticism that many say helped to bring down the regime itself. The Russians had grown angry with Bakiyev last year after he reneged on a promise to evict from Kyrgyzstan an American air base—the Transit Center at Manas—that supplies the war effort in Afghanistan. Bakiyev made the initial announcement after receiving a $2 billion loan guarantee from Moscow, and it was widely understood that the threat to kick out the Americans was a quid pro quo. But four months later, after the United States offered to more than triple the amount of money it was paying to “rent” the land on which the base sits, Bakiyev reneged.

Gourevitch’s current whereabouts are unknown. Rumors swirling around Bishkek had him taking a private plane to Moscow, Tel Aviv, or New York. Maxim, who had landed in Washington, D.C., for a U.S.-government sponsored development conference by the time his father had been ousted, is suspected to be in Latvia.

The recent disturbances are something that Reichman is visibly uncomfortable talking about. When I meet him at the dingy, cramped, and gated compound that serves as the headquarters for the country’s Jewish community and that houses its only synagogue, he waves off speculation that they are in any way indicative of a deeper problem in the country. “The Kyrgyz people are very hospitable and warm-hearted,” he insists. “This is supported by the fact that Jews have lived here untroubled.” Yet when asked whether or not it is fair to say that the alleged ties between a Jewish businessman and the corrupt family that ruled Kyrgyzstan are responsible for the expression of anti-Semitic sentiments, Reichman notes, “The people did not come to Gourevitch’s house. They came to the synagogue.”

Reichman recently wrote a letter to the leaders of the interim government expressing the community’s concern about potential anti-Semitism, but the hastily arranged group of 14 former opposition politicians now running the country have yet to respond. Given the tasks facing them, that’s understandable. And Reichman dismisses concerns about the safety of his flock. “We don’t see a constant threat, a danger for future attacks or assaults,” he tells me. “We think that this was a singular act of aggression, and we hope that it won’t happen again.”

James Kirchick is Writer at Large with Radio Free Europe/Radio Liberty based in Prague and a Contributing Editor to The New Republic.

Print Email
reporter says:

Goureveitch was arrested in Kazakhstan some time ago,…furthermore this article omits almost all of the other frauds he was involved in.

Not a particularly well researched article at all.

witness says:

The content of the article, while not fully researched, was not altogether inaccurate. Troubling how misleading and inflammatory the title of the article is, especially considering the tone of the rest of the article. Not clear whether the author or the editor were trying to push hits to this site, but that either would denote the entire nation as a bastion of anti-semitism based on such flimsy evidence and research is quite disappointing.

Sliman says:

The choice of the title for the article is very puzzling.
I can only assume that by “satellite” we should understand the country Kyrgyzstan. Exactly whose satellite is it? This is the only country in the world which has both a Russian and an American military base.
If one Molotov’s cocktail thrown at a synagogue and one handwritten sign in public place for one day during a revolution(!) constitutes the whole country being an island of HATE, the author at the very least severely delusional. If in France we routinely witness synagogues and Jewish cemeteries being attacked in times of peace (and can’t imagine what will go on if there’s a suspension of law and order) I wonder what sort of choice of words the author has for that country.

“Anti-Semitism erupts”, really? I won’t even go into the discussion of the subtitle.

James Kirchick, if there was any shred of credibility you ever had, I think that this article pretty much killed it off, as well as probably contributing to marginals reinforcing their own beliefs about “Jews spewing groundless propaganda”, and in this case I would actually agree.
Pure drivel, James, pure drivel.

Marty says:

Please explain to me “WHY DO ANY JEWS STAY IN THESE EASTERN EUROPEAN COUNTRIES” ????

This article completely ignores the fact that general anti foreign (and even though Jews have lived in the Kyrgyz Republic for a long time, they are still considered “outsiders” or “foreigners”) activity took place just after the events in April. Uzbeks, Chinese, Turks and other minorities were also targeted. Having lived in Kyrgyzstan previously and had close ties to the country and its people for well over a decade, I find these reports of rampant anti Semitism to be overblown almost to the point of ridiculousness.

I am Jewish. I lived all over the former Soviet Union over a number of years and had real hate spewed in my face more than once. Never in Kyrgyzstan. I found the Kyrgyz to be among the most open-minded in regards to their minorities.

One sign and one attack in a night full of destruction of all kinds does not a pogrom make.

You wrote about several engaging things in this article. I found this article by using Yahoo and I have to confess that I am now subscribed to the website, it is very good :D

Hi my loved one! I want to say that this post is amazing, great written and include almost all vital infos. I¡¦d like to peer extra posts like this .

Good stuff. I even agree with all of it except Satellite of Hate – by James Kirchick > Tablet Magazine – A New Read on Jewish Life

Random Google results can occasionally lead to great blogs like this. You’re doing a good job, and we share a lot of thoughts.

Great paintings! This is the kind of info that are supposed to be shared around the net. Shame on the search engines for now not positioning this submit higher! Come on over and visit my site . Thanks =)

2000

Your comment may be no longer than 2,000 characters, approximately 400 words. HTML tags are not permitted, nor are more than two URLs per comment. We reserve the right to delete inappropriate comments.

Thank You!

Thank you for subscribing to the Tablet Magazine Daily Digest.
Please tell us about you.

Satellite of Hate

In Kyrgyzstan, anti-Semitism erupts in the wake of the president’s ouster

More on Tablet:

The Blame Game

By Batya Ungar-Sargon — New York State starves schools of money. In East Ramapo, Orthodox Jews—and special-needs children—get the blame.