Your email is not valid
Recipient's email is not valid
Submit Close

Your email has been sent.

Click here to send another

Indispensable

Michael Oren, Israel’s U.S. ambassador, says Washington will always need his country as an ally

Print Email
Michael Oren speaks during Holocaust Remembrance Day ceremony at the U.S. Capitol on April 15, 2010. (Astrid Riecken/Getty Images)

Michael Oren, a 55-year-old U.S.-born historian of the modern Middle East and the author of two best-selling books, one on the 1967 Arab-Israeli war and another on the United States’ 200-year-old experience in the Middle East, renounced his U.S. citizenship at an emotional ceremony in Tel Aviv last May to become Israel’s ambassador to Washington. In addition to a military record as one of Israel’s elite warriors, Oren has both the common touch and the ability to speak extemporaneously, and for long stretches, on minute details of contemporary Middle East history and politics—all qualities that suited him for the job.

If Oren came to the post fully aware of some of the challenges and threats Israel was to face during his tenure, most notably the Iranian nuclear program, there was little to indicate that he would also watch up close the historic changes in the special relationship between his two countries. Last week, as the full effect of the Gaza flotilla story started to take hold, I sat with him in his Washington office and asked him how long Israel can keep up its naval blockade, especially now that the Obama Administration says it is unsustainable. “We, too, believe that the status quo needs to be changed,” said the ambassador. “And we are open to suggestions.”

It’s worth recalling that Israel’s blockade of Gaza is the result of U.S. policy, specifically the George W. Bush Administration’s freedom agenda. Secretary of State Condoleezza Rice badgered the Palestinian Authority’s Mahmoud Abbas to make sure that P.A. elections were held on schedule in January 2006, after which the United States couldn’t contest the poll results that brought Hamas to power. After that, Israel and the United States, along with the rest of the members of the Middle East Quartet (comprised of the United States, the European Union, the United Nations, and Russia) leveled economic sanctions in order to weaken Hamas. In turn, Hamas showed just how strong it was by crushing Fatah in the 2007 Palestinian civil war that left the former in charge of Gaza. With U.S. diplomacy incapable of unseating the Islamist outfit that had come to power through both the democratic elections that Washington championed and the violence it condemned, Israel imposed a blockade to limit the amount of rockets and missiles smuggled into Gaza and then fired at Israeli homes. To end the blockade without accounting for Israeli security, says Oren, would put an end to the peace process. “Hamas will create a situation with a vast missile arsenal and it will gain further popularity,” he said to me. “Who needs peace with Israel if you can make war?”

The attention given the flotilla incident left Oren almost relieved to answer questions about the Iranian nuclear program. How long, I asked him, can Israel afford to abide by a process managed by the United States before it gets off the bus and decides it has to act alone against Iran?

“It definitely is a managed process,” said Oren. “And we signed on to it. President Obama’s tactics follow a linear trajectory—first there was outreach, then compromise, and now we’re at the threshold of what we hope will be effective sanctions. We’ll see what the Russians and Chinese do.”

I noted that there are many people, not only in U.S. and Israeli policymaking circles but also among our Arab allies, who believe it is too late for sanctions. Oren has doubts: “Even a whiff of sanctions spurred the Iranians to sign on with the deal the Turks and Brazilians offered,” he said. Nonetheless, the ambassador admits that right now it’s hard to know the exact signs that will tell Israel sanctions aren’t sufficient and that Jerusalem will have to go it alone. “I believe that President Obama’s position on Iran is far more muscular than is widely perceived,” he said. “He has said he is determined to prevent an Iranian nuclear weapon and I do believe he is.”

“A strong American disposition is an Israeli strategic interest,” said Oren. I asked him if Washington’s role in the region is changing, whether the United States has the same leverage that it did a decade ago. “It’s in the middle of a withdrawal from one conflict [Iraq], and a pledge to withdraw from another [Afghanistan],” Oren said, “and this is perceived in the Middle East with antennae well attuned to shifts in power.”

Even Washington’s customary habit in the Middle East of offering financial incentives is limited. “The U.S. is reeling from a severe economic recession as well as ecological challenges and a reorganization of domestic priorities,” said Oren. “This doesn’t mean that the U.S. is not still a major player. In terms of mediation, it’s the only show in town.”

Nonetheless, among Israeli officials like Mossad chief Meir Dagan there’s a growing belief that the White House is disburdening the United States of its involvement in conflicts, and I asked the ambassador if he believes that the process of unburdening includes Washington distancing itself from its conflict-prone Israeli ally. Even before the flotilla incident, Israel’s stock had seemed to be dropping inside the Beltway. Israel’s wars with Hezbollah in summer 2006 and Gaza in the winter of 2008 to 2009 alienated segments of the U.S. intelligentsia, including American Jews, who were flummoxed, they said, that the Jewish state did not abide by higher moral standards than other countries, including the United States. However, those same two wars left Washington worried that Israel can no longer get the job done. Once a strategic asset whose unrivaled power (coupled with unconditional U.S. support) kept peace in the eastern Mediterranean, Israel has become, according to Anthony Cordesman, an analyst at the Center for Strategic and International Studies and one of the pillars of the Beltway’s think-tank community, a strategic liability.

Oren disagrees. “We are aware that this is a certain body of thought in the Washington bureaucracies and the think-tank world, but it is not so with the American people or policymakers,” he said. “Israel is the only democratic American ally in the Middle East that can field a highly trained combat-proven army in 12 hours.”

Indeed, among other things, the Mavi Marmara incident revealed that the Turks are not the friends of Washington that they once were, leaving only Israel as capable, and willing, to stand by the United States as a reliable ally in the Middle East. “The U.S. can leave Vietnam confident that North Vietnamese tanks are not going to roll through U.S. cities,” said Oren. “But with the Middle East you’re not going anywhere because it will follow you—to Times Square, to the airspace over Detroit. Israel is described as the U.S.’s aircraft carrier in the Middle East. If the U.S. had an Israel in the Persian Gulf it might not have had to land troops in Iraq twice over the last two decades. Israel is the indispensable nation.”

Jerusalem may have a chance to remind Washington of the fact in the coming months. When I remarked that many Israelis are expecting war this summer, Oren made no efforts to dispel it as a rumor. “We are concerned about this,” he said, explaining that with sanctions coming up at the United Nations, the Iranians may once again try to spark a war in Lebanon, as they did when their nuclear program was referred to the U.N. Security Council in 2006. “We face a different situation than we did in 2006, and it is much worse,” Oren said. “Hezbollah has rearmed so that it now has 42,000 missiles that can hit Eilat,” Israel’s southernmost city. In 2006, the Israelis destroyed all of Hezbollah’s long- and medium-range missiles during the war’s opening salvo, but now, said Oren, “Hezbollah has hidden all of its medium- and long-range missiles under schools and hospitals. They internalized Goldstone.”

In other words, while it was widely reported during the course of the Gaza war that the Hamas leadership was hiding out in Gaza’s Al-Shifa hospital, Israel knew that an attack on a hospital would earn it the opprobrium of the international community. Even then Israel still wound up facing the United Nations Fact Finding Mission on the Gaza Conflict, commonly known as the Goldstone Report. For Israel, a third Hezbollah war is about cleaning up its backyard regardless of whether or not the Party of God’s sponsors in Tehran enrich enough uranium to build a bomb. The United States also has a vital interest in its ally disabling the asset of an Iranian adversary that challenges Washington’s half-century hegemony in the Persian Gulf—an interest that may or may not be more important to the Obama Administration than its efforts to seek rapprochement with the world’s 1.3 billion Muslims.

However, if Israel’s adversaries believe that they can put Israel on the defensive by shaming it in the court of public opinion through the use of human shields, Oren says, they may have miscalculated. For if the Jewish state is condemned when it plays by the normal rules of warfare that apply to the United States and its allies in Iraq and Afghanistan, then maybe Israel will stop trying to figure out how to satisfy the capricious dictates of the international community and act to defend itself and defeat its enemies.

“Our critics don’t get it,” Oren said. “In Jenin, we went house-to-house and sent 23 soldiers to their death. But if we’re going to be called war criminals no matter what we do, then maybe that changes our thinking.”

Print Email
Alan says:

Excellent interview. Mr. Oren’s responses and his general view of the Arab/Israeli conflict were both spot-on and refreshing in
candor.

Thank you!

Oren was an American?? Could have fooled me.

Israel has a choice: Whether to be the victor or the victim. Sometimes the victor has to be the oppressor in order to avoid being the victim. So be it.

As far world public opinion goes – Who cares? The world is very comfortable with Jews as victims. The world will cluck its collective tongue and say, “Isn’t it a shame about what happened to all those poor Jews.” But the world feels very awkward and is downright uncomfortable when Jews refuse to be the victims and successfully defend themselves. Then the world collectively huffs, “Why can’t you be good little Jews and accept your fate.”

Israels fate is in its own hands. Always has been.

Lyric says:

Few countries, if any, other than Israel and the US seem to consider so completely from every conceivable angle, the effects of the actions the country takes. It would be nice if that were not the case!

jeff says:

I have noticed that the only time israel is not trashed is when jews die on mass. so i have come to the conclusion that the trashing of israel is a sign that israel has done something good (like protect its citizens)

Shirley Threet says:

Mr.Oren is on the mark. God made a covenant with Moses for the people of Israel to have their land forever.

steve says:

This was a good interview. However, I found this part noteworthy: …..Gaza in the winter of 2008 to 2009 alienated segments of the U.S. intelligentsia, including American Jews,…that the Jewish state did not abide by higher moral standards than other countries, including the United States.” If this is really true, they were poorly informed. Are we comparing Israel’s actions to the high standards of Russia vs. Chechnya, No Korea against South Korea, Sudan in Darfur? As for the USA we have made more than a few mistakes with our Predators. We killed the #3 in AlQaeda recently but also his wife and children. We killed many civilians in Iraq and Afghanistan. Yet Obama is focused on those Turkish “peace” activists. So Lee Smith, it was a very informative interview, but which countries abide by higher moral standards?

Sparky Satori says:

How’s your final solution to the Palestine problem coming along?

The Other Alan says:

Oren doesn’t get it. Zionism is predicated on dominating Palestine’s native population to the degree necessary to establish a Jewish controlled and oriented state. Its essence has never been cooperation, and its adherents have worked tirelessly to inflict enough pain that the Arab population accepts its defeat and subservience to Jewish interests.

But as the prophet Micah noted, this mindset is wrong. The longer Israel holds to the Zionist ideology, the more tenuous its existence, regardless of the spin men like Oren may put on things. The noose is tightening year by year. It’s not Israel, but Israel’s ideology.

Micah 2:1 Woe to them that devise iniquity, and work evil upon their beds! when the morning is light, they practise it, because it is in the power of their hand.

Micah 2:2 And they covet fields, and take them by violence; and houses, and take them away: so they oppress a man and his house, even a man and his heritage.

Micah 2:3 Therefore thus saith the LORD; Behold, against this family do I devise an evil, from which ye shall not remove your necks; neither shall ye go haughtily: for this time is evil.

It is true we have to deal with President Obama but we don’t have to give in to his chaning theories.War isn’t won by people with opposite ideologies. Each of these mid-east countires wants to be the leader in the field- it’s just that Saudi Arabia is aaid of the conflicting rise of the tribal clans.

Jacob Zeder says:

As long as Israel holds on to its Zionist ideology? Does this make sense? If there is no Zionist ideology there is no Israel-oh never mine I get where you are coming from.

samg says:

i don’t see a shred of evidence to support the headline of this story: that israel is and always will be “indispensable” to american security. if anybody can find anything like that in here, i wish you’d point it out to me.

Honest Broker says:

Israel is and always will be “indispensable” to American security.
Dreaming in Technicolor.The US like other state have only interests not morals inspired by someone else’s Biblical vision

Hi there, I found your blog via Google while looking for a related topic, your website came up, it looks great. I’ve bookmarked it in my google bookmarks.

God help me, I put aside a whole aefrntoon to figure this out.

I and my friends came studying the good helpful hints found on your web site while then came up with an awful feeling I had not thanked the blog owner for those strategies. All the guys had been stimulated to study all of them and have undoubtedly been making the most of these things. Thank you for being very considerate as well as for pick out this kind of extraordinary useful guides millions of individuals are really desperate to know about. Our own sincere apologies for not saying thanks to sooner.

I’ve said that least 3837357 times. The problem this like that is they are just too compilcated for the average bird, if you know what I mean

I would like to thank you for the efforts you have put in writing this blog. I am hoping the same high-grade site post from you in the upcoming also. In fact your creative writing skills has encouraged me to get my own web site now. Actually the blogging is spreading its wings rapidly. Your write up is a good example of it.

2000

Your comment may be no longer than 2,000 characters, approximately 400 words. HTML tags are not permitted, nor are more than two URLs per comment. We reserve the right to delete inappropriate comments.

Thank You!

Thank you for subscribing to the Tablet Magazine Daily Digest.
Please tell us about you.

Indispensable

Michael Oren, Israel’s U.S. ambassador, says Washington will always need his country as an ally

More on Tablet:

Zara Pulls Yellow Star Shirt After Online Outrage

By Stephanie Butnick — Blue and white-striped pajama shirt supposedly inspired by Western movies