Your email is not valid
Recipient's email is not valid
Submit Close

Your email has been sent.

Click here to send another

A History of Violence

It wasn’t just a case of bullying when a 16-year-old Jewish boy was beaten up in a small German town where hate runs deep

Print Email
A Volkswagen in Laucha, Germany. (Frank Rothe)

As the four of us drove into Laucha, the possibility of violence seemed remote. To the east and the west, vineyards dotted the landscape, and a cheerful sign at the entrance to town toasted the local resident crowned that year’s Wine Queen. The town’s medieval houses and narrow streets sat under a looming church spire, watching sternly over the small square at Laucha’s center.

Leo’s house looks no different than the other stone houses in town. Sitting at the simple dinner table shortly after returning from high school, Leo bore no marks from the attack. His attitude, too, was defiant; even though he had lived in Laucha for most of his life, his accent made him sound more Israeli than German.

“I’m not afraid,” Leo said to me in Hebrew about living in this remote town. “I consider myself also an Israeli, but I can’t see myself living in Israel. My friends are here, my connections are here, I’ve been here from the age of 7. As a Jew, I cannot run or hide. To the contrary, I have a right to live where I want. Precisely because of what happened to my grandparents.”

When asked if he’s angry with the Germans—a question that many of his relatives in Israel raised in the days immediately following the attack—Leo shook his head. But he did feel, he admitted, that what happened to him was brushed off by far too many of his schoolmates as a mere act of bullying. He wished, he said, that people in Laucha would realize the attack was very different from a mere violent outburst.

“My generation is all the time asking not to connect them to the past,” he said. “But if that’s the case then they are supposed to be much more angry than me about this incident. They cannot let that happen. Unless they like to be called Nazis.”

As I was talking to Leo, Frank Rothe, a photographer, left to take some snapshots of Laucha. He shot the pastoral countryside, the ancient municipal plaza, people going about their daily lives. Then, he arrived at the field where Lutz Battke was presiding over soccer practice. Rothe introduced himself to Battke, and Battke told him curtly that no photography was allowed at the club. Rothe replied that since the club was municipal property, he could snap shots whenever he wished. Battke pulled out his battered Nokia cell phone, said a few things to the person on the other end of the line, and handed the phone over to Rothe. Michael Bilstein, the soccer team’s vice president and Laucha’s current mayor, tried to convince Rothe to leave, but Rothe wouldn’t budge. When the conversation finally came to an end, Rothe flipped the cell phone shut. A screen saver came on the phone’s small display. It was a portrait of Adolf Hitler.

***

After hearing Rothe’s account, I wanted to chat with Lutz Battke. He wasn’t at the practice field, so, accompanied by my volunteer bodyguards, I drove to his house and climbed up to the second floor. The shoes Battke had just worn during the football practice were outside the door. I knocked. A woman opened the door, saw my face, and slammed it immediately. I knocked again. There was no answer.

Outside in the street, a young man with short blond hair agreed to answer our questions. He claimed he had never heard of Leo. We told him he was an Israeli-born boy who was beat up by a bully for being a Jew. “Should he even be here?” the young blond asked. “And should you?”

The young man, we later learned from neighbors, was Ronnie, Lutz Battke’s adopted son.

As Battke himself was nowhere to be found, I decided to talk to those residents of Laucha who supported his enterprise. One is Olaf Pleitz, the proprietor of a local company that supplies sanitary appliances and tools for hospitals. Pleitz is one of the key financial sponsors of Battke’s football club. When I called to ask why he was sponsoring a man who had Hitler on his screen saver and goons on his football squad, Pleitz erupted. He shouted that he had the right to sponsor whomever he damn pleased, and that he can’t possibly know what goes on in all of the many organizations he supports.

He was right—as a business owner, he owed no explanation for his actions. That, however, wasn’t the case with Rotkäppchen, a producer of sparkling wine and another enthusiastic sponsor of Battke’s club. The company’s owner, a man with the surname Heise, lives on Tannengartnen Strasse in Laucha, a three-minute ride from Tzipi Lev and Olaf Osteroth’s house and from the practice field where his firm’s sign decorates the fence. When we pulled into his driveway, his wife was leaving the house. We asked her if it was possible talk to Heise, and she said he wasn’t home and asked what we wanted. We said we wanted to know whether Heise could tell us why his firm sponsors a football club that employs a known right-wing extremist as one of its leaders. She took our contacts.

Eight minutes later, Claudia Korenke, one of the firm’s spokespeople, called us from Frankfurt. She talked at length about Herr Heise’s activities to strengthen Germany’s relations with Israel. After I pressed her on the company’s ties to Battke, she promised to get back to me. The next day, she emailed to let me know that Rotkäppchen had decided to cut all ties and sponsorship deals with the club.

I called Alexander Palloch, the bully; his mother said her boy was innocent because he was a Protestant, and therefore forbidden by God from hating foreigners. I called the police to complain about Battke’s Hitler screen saver—based on German laws prohibiting display of Nazi imagery—but the police said that whatever Battke chose to do with his cell phone was his private business. I also called Mayor Bilstein. I wasn’t expecting much; after the attack, Bilstein told local media that there was no evidence that Battke was connected to the attack, and that the children adored him. “[Battke] works with young children, and I do not believe he has bad influence on them,” he said. “We’ve never heard complaints from parents about him. If there were complaints, that would be another story.” But when I finally got him on the phone, the mayor sounded contrite. Leo’s attacker, he said, “comes from a broken home, he escaped from school, and the only guidance he had came from the football club. We can’t allow NPD supporters to coach and teach in this club.” He promised to look into Battke’s politics and vowed that he would resign his position as the club’s vice president if Battke wasn’t removed from his position as coach.

“In 1999, we thought that the club would help to integrate people like Battke into society,” Bilstein told me on the phone. “It is now 2010, and we must admit that we failed. We have succeeded in sports, but everyone is just talking about the Nazi team of Laucha.”

The following day, the Laucha police called again. They told me that they had decided to open an investigation concerning Lutz Battke’s screen saver.

Hearing this bit of news, Lev and Osteroth were happy but not thrilled. They were fighting, they said, for their hometown, a place ravaged by decades of dictatorship before the reunification and years of economic hardship after it. They believed that if people in Laucha had the chance to meet Jewish people, the old animosities would disappear. They also believed that anti-Semitism in Laucha was just a convenient vehicle for material frustrations, not some deep-seated belief. They believed all that, but they weren’t sure. If they turned out to be wrong, they said, they’d pack up and leave, maybe for Israel.

Toward the end of our stay in Laucha, Osteroth took me up in one of his hot-air balloons, and we floated above the region’s green fields. Osteroth said that as long as his family was here, they had to fight. “The role of my generation is not to look back in shame, but to ensure that there will be no closing of the eyes in the present,” he said. He pointed down, toward the center of town. “Otherwise,” he added, “place after place here will become Naziland.”

***

Sign Up for special curated mailings of the best longform content from Tablet Magazine.

1 2View as single page
Print Email
MaxS says:

It’s not clear to me why Jews are living in Germany. Haven’t we gotten the message yet?

Lisa Kaiser says:

Why should we not live in Germany? Why should we let neo-Nazis try to intimidate us? The message from WWII is that hatred is destructive. We stand up for ourselves and live where we want to live.

Yaakov Freiburger says:

Lisa,
there is no future for Jews in Germany. If it´s not neo-nazis, you have the growing Muslim community (I think I don´t have to tell you about Muslim anti-Semitism, do I?), or then it´s assimilation altogether.
I can´t understand why some Israelis prefer to leave their country to go to that place. We should all go to Israel, that is our land.

Jews should livein Germany for one of two, or maybe both,reasons. One, they love the country of their birth and feel comfortable there and free to live where they wish to. Two, because if every Jew abandoned Germany,it woud be tantamount to giving the country up tothe neo-nazis—giving they a place of their own from which they can build their forces and gradually overwhelmt he rest of the country. Who’s to stop them?

A Jewish person of my age (50) finds it bizarre that any Jew would want to live in Germany. But, I could also say the same about Jews who want to live in Poland, Ukraine, Czechoslovakia, etc. Maybe younger people know the history but aren’t affected by it enough to be intimidated.

What can I say? A German accent still gives me the creeps.

Jack Glasner says:

I have no sympathy for Jews who live in GERMANY, matter of fact Europe is a nest of Jew haters.. We JEWS never learn.

EdwinS says:

From what I know I’d prefer to be a Jew in Germany than in the UK or France.
Today’s Germany is not the Third Reich – by any means.

Dani Levi says:

I have many German Jewish friends who could never imagine living anywhere else, because Germany is their home, they are German. Having said that living in Saxony-Anhalt is beyond most people with an IQ over 100, even gentiles. The US equivalent would be some dump in Texas where they chain gays to a pick up truck and drag him down a dirt path to his death, or HEY I hear killing Latinos is all the “rage” on Long Island, or what about Arizona?! ” they sure put the nAZi in Arizona ” yada yada yada….and so the story goes.
Hebrew knee jerk reaction towards terrible stories like these help nobody. German Jewish communities are growing and booming in the cities, Berlin seems to have more Israeli creatives than Tel Aviv. So, just take a breath and chill. This is a new generation, even my friends, who’s parents are Survivors are happy. And they sure do not appreciate other diaspora Jews judging them like some do in this thread.

In a way Hitler won his battle against the above nay sayers. But he did not beat down those observant Hebrews I know.
Shalom.

Sharon from WI says:

What I’d like to know is since when is a 20-year-old man considered a teen-ager? This assault was committed by a grown man on a child.

The Jew hatred of the Nazis led to the murders of millions of Jews and this created a vacuum in the societies of Europe. After WW 2 the Nazis threw off their uniforms and faded into the Communist parties of Europe, and the vacuum left by millions of murdered Jews has been filled by millions of Muslim immigrants who are no less Jew haters than were the Nazis, and no less than the Communists. Thus the left wing activists defend the like minded immigrants, and old school anti-Semites like the thug in this story flail about with a surfeit of targets unaware they have caused the problem. See
What the Left Really Thinks of Hitler
http://sultanknish.blogspot.com/2010/07/what-left-really-thinks-of-hitler.html

Rachel says:

Right you are, Dani.Today’s Germany is not Hitler’s Germany, and I myself have lived half my life in Saxony-Anhalt,in a town not much bigger than Laucha,that back then was still in GDR (East Germany).My grandparents kept telling me not to tell anybody we were Jewishwhen I was a child, and when after re-unification they did tell and were asked why they had chosen to live in Germany,my grandma used to say:”I didn’t want Hitler to win.Germany shall never be “judenrein”!” (Nazi-word for free of Jews).She was a brave woman, and so was my Granddad (he survived three camps).When in 1988 demonstartors in Leipzig in 1989shouted “Wir bleiben hier” (We will stay here!) she kept nodding.
I do know that my mom and her siblings have faced anti-semitism at school and at work back then, and their Sasi(GDR secret service)-files, even mine, were full of words like “possible Zionist agent”, etc..At school we were taught that zionism was the highest (and thus worst) sort of imperialsm, the word for evil in this communist regime.
Today I feel I’m better off in the Western part of Germany,e.g. my children benefit from better educational opportunities, we have good jobs, many friends (gentiles,too).But I keep visiting my family in Saxony-Anhalt.
I really think (my experience)that e.g. France today is not a bit less anti-semitic than even the worst areas of East Germany.

Talia says:

An accurate and important article. I’m a Jewish woman living in a small town in western Germany and very happy to see reporting about what’s happening in these villages. The NPD is a real and active threat in the places where they are entrenched, and this summer has been a violent one throughout Germany. We need a lot more support from diaspora Jews to increase pressure on the German government and media to not minimize, disbelieve, or refuse to investigate/prosecute the more and more blatant acts of violence.

TheDevilCanDance says:

Give me a break , all of you professional whiners forget that a young American Jew lost her eye in Israel a couple of months ago, because she was opposing the destruction of Palestinians. Another young female, Rachel Cory, was crushed to death by an IDF bulldozer, & on and on….. You people are disgusting, when someone deemed as “one of yours” is aggressed, injured or killed, the earth has to stop its rotation, but when Goys experience the same, it become statistics…..and always justified.
Both your contempt for non Jewish human life, & your obsession with your own pseudo racial identity is pathological & neurotic

TheDevilCanDance says:

Yaakov Freiburger

No,Israel is not your land, if you are Ukrainian, you stay in Ukraine, if you are German, you stay in Germany. I can also write a “book” full of idiotic and superstitious garbages and pretend that my”God” gave me ownership of a particular piece of real estate.

By the way, my god is telling me that I have the right to impose & collect taxes, upon any individual whose name starts with a Y…..

Lol. Jews are as loony as their Muslim & Christian cousins

lovelyisraelis says:

Actually, Jews decided to make their OWN “Naziland” where they were the racist overlords. They have been quite successful in this undertaking, and would have impressed the German Nazis whose tactics they have emulated.

Free Palestine.

Fnord says:

It may be worth pointing out that the staunchest opposition to the neo-nazis is Germany comes from the far left, who so many Americans see as anti-semite because of their position on Israeli policies…

Dani Levi says:

It is noteworthy how stories like these have the Israel haters come out. Going on from Lee Smiths last article in Tablet, the dynamic is an interesting one how anti-Semites will choose any nail to hang themselves.

TheDevilCanDance says:

Dani Levi

Hahaha, It is so easy indeed to build a vision of the world where Jews are systematically victimized and threatened by the rest of humanity (the whole universe is antisemitic according to the majority of Jews…),but when some members of the Jewish community oppose & speak against the moral decay of Israel society, they are labeled as “self hating Jews..”
The good Jews always win in your monolithic world.

But your response shows the depth of your idiocy, you called me antisemitic without even knowing if I am a Jew or a Goy.

stan nadel says:

S. Wolf repeats the usual right wing crap about ex-Nazis all becoming Communists after WWII and therefore the whole left is Antisemitic. In West Germany leading ex-Nazis held high positions in Adenauer’s government and the German civil service while their counterparts in East Germany joined the Communists and in Austria joined either the Conservatives or the Social Democrats or their own Freedom Party (as it was called later). By Wolf’s logic the West German Conservatives and all the Austrians must also be Antisemites. As a long term Jewish resident of Austria I can assure everyone that while there is no shortage of neo-Nazis here, they are like their German counterparts less than 25% of the total and they are counterbalanced these days by large numbers of anti-Nazis.

As for why I would live here as a Jew, one reason is to deny Hitler the victory of making this place Judenrein.

Argamon says:

Actually I see Zev Living-in-Berlin article and the talkbacks as very unilluminating. This is really all old stuff; story the same, characters different. The ‘Devil…’ and ‘Lovely”… are possibly of Jewish descent (vinegar son of wine). If you have have Helen Thomas’ email, or that of Professor Walt, you might want to forward.

steve says:

to theDevil Can Dance:
read again what dani wrote: about you: “Israel hater” Dani’s comment about antisemitic referred to the Lee Smith article. In Smith’s article, many comments were anti-Jewish. In fact, Tablet has also fallen prey to smith’s theory on hate speech: Tablet wants to drive eyeball counts.

As for your comments what is so striking is the anger that delivers them. But nothing so finely tuned as lovelyisraelis above, who compares the Israelis to the Nazis,writing, “would have impressed the German Nazis whose tactics they have emulated.” Really?

Interestingly,Oliver Stone’s defense of his comments was that the Nazis killed more russians than Jews. So what was it, 20 million? And here is lovelyisraelis writing about emulation?

You see thedevilcandance, your unsubstantiated anger and accusations are unfortunate but check your anger, because it is nothing like the stupidity of lovelyisraelis hateful comments.

Finally, a shout out to TABLET itself; it seems that the more thoughtful the piece, the more it encourages ignorant Jew hating ranters in its comment section.This one is child’s play to soome of the other’s. But hey, they write about the conversion bill and what do you find: “comments are closed”. One can only wonder the junk that would have come out of the sewer to take on Alana Newhouse’s favorite cause….even though she demagogued it as well.

2000

Your comment may be no longer than 2,000 characters, approximately 400 words. HTML tags are not permitted, nor are more than two URLs per comment. We reserve the right to delete inappropriate comments.

Thank You!

Thank you for subscribing to the Tablet Magazine Daily Digest.
Please tell us about you.

A History of Violence

It wasn’t just a case of bullying when a 16-year-old Jewish boy was beaten up in a small German town where hate runs deep

More on Tablet:

A Rosh Hashanah Meal With Meaning

By Rachel Harkham — Recipes featuring the Talmud’s five ingredients for a sweet new year