Your email is not valid
Recipient's email is not valid
Submit Close

Your email has been sent.

Click here to send another

Qaddafi’s Captive

When Israeli artist Rafram Chaddad visited Libya to document its once-thriving Jewish community, he was accused of espionage and put in jail. Now free, he tells of his five months in captivity.

Print Email
Photographer Rafram Chaddad (right) arriving at Ben Gurion airport with Israeli Foreign Minister Avigdor Lieberman, August 9, 2010. (Yossi Zamir-Pool/Getty Images)

With the exception of one relatively benign and short interrogation by authorities in the port city of Derna, Chaddad’s rigid 10-day schedule in Libya was uneventful. He was able to survey the vast and picturesque desert landscapes across the country and catalog the relics of what had been one of the most culturally affluent Jewish communities in North Africa. During his wide-ranging travels there, he experienced what he now understands to have been a false sense of security. “I eventually came to realize that every second person I met in Libya was working for the secret police,” he says. “At my trial, I even encountered a security agent who had acted as my taxi driver a few days earlier.”

Thrown into his prison cell by the two agents who had picked him up from the hotel, Chaddad had plenty of time to reassess the various people he’d met. The cell in the prison where Chaddad spent his first weeks of captivity was about 6 by 6 and constructed out of barren concrete. With nothing but a chewed-up mattress with broken springs poking through it, a broken toilet, and no company but the family of cockroaches in the corner, Chaddad remained confused but optimistic. A small barred window facing an illuminated hallway allowed him to retain a sense of time.

The initial interrogations, he recalls, were relatively bland, mechanical, almost boring. A young and cologne-scented investigator named Imad questioned him repeatedly about his comings and goings in Libya. Sitting in a room with nothing but two chairs and a desk, Imad would write down every word Chaddad said. “The first alarming question he asked me was regarding the last time I visited Israel,” Chaddad remembers. Saying that he was currently living in London, Hadad did not veer too far from the truth; he explained he was a Jewish-Tunisian photographer chronicling the remains of the local Jewish community. “I didn’t want to push it, so I admitted that I visited family in Israel a few times,” he says. Rather than dismay him, the questions about Israel apparently only heightened Chaddad’s sense of optimism. “From this I understood that they were clueless,” he says. (After all, he had been living in Israel most of his life.) “I started to believe that I would come out of this in a few days.”

One remarkable thing about Chaddad’s surprisingly precise recollection of the events is its culinary foundations. Rather than remember the course of events through a sequential narrative of days, he remembers it through the various meals he ate. The first Sunday there was “a nice tuna sandwich, with some delicate harissa,” a Tunisian chili. Similarly, he can describe the flavor of the stuffing in the meat, the sweetness of the oranges, and the spicing on the macaroni he was fed in prison. In Libya, he didn’t always eat—in fact, he went days at a time without food—but this appreciation of even the most quotidian of things is a testament to the vitality that also helped him survive the ordeal.

***

During Chaddad’s first days in prison, not only was he not accused of any specific crime, but even more distressingly, he was not even told where he was or who was detaining him. “All this time, I could only keep thinking about my mom, and how she must be worrying about me,” he recalls. After all, no one had any knowledge of his whereabouts, and for all anyone knew he could be dead. Despite pleading unsuccessfully with his captors to inform his relatives in Tunisia of his arrest, word of his detainment would eventually reach his family by way of another prisoner who was interned with him. Chaddad remembers that in one of the adjacent cells, there was a prisoner with a distinct English accent, who was constantly bellowing in pain. Having prompted a conversation with him by singing some choice Beatles hits, Chaddad came to learn that the young man, who went by the name of Mathew, was a British citizen who had come to Libya, fallen in love with a Muslim girl, and was now awaiting deportation. On the eve of Mathew’s departure, Chaddad had the sense to drill his sister’s email address into Mathew’s memory by repeatedly singing it in a catchy tune. Despite Chaddad’s initial suspicions about Mathew’s identity—“I was sure he was planted there by the Libyans,” he says—the British man ended up delivering. The night he returned to England, Mathew sent Hadad’s sister an email that eloquently depicted Chaddad’s grave situation. It read: “Your brother is in deep shit.”

Although Chaddad’s family eventually got word of his fate and could set in motion the momentous diplomatic pressures that would eventually bring about his release, his immediate fate was about to take a turn for the worse. What Mathew had neglected to tell Hadad for fear of unnerving him was that the Libyan security services had their own diabolical ways of extracting information from their prisoners—as Hadad was about to find out. Having checked a fake email account Chaddad had specifically created for the trip and given them, his investigators demanded the password to his real email account. “That’s when I understood it was time to spill it,” he says. “One week exactly after my arrest, I tell Imad, ‘Listen, I have something for you that will knock you off your feet: I am Israeli.’ ”

The retribution was swift and painful: “An older investigator, Ali, comes in and tells me, ‘I am now going to beat you, because you lied to us,’ ” Chaddad says. “I thought he was kidding. But then they tied my hands behind my back with handcuffs, grabbed my legs and lifted them up, and started beating the soles of my feet with a wooden stick. This went on for about 20 minutes, during which I was constantly asking myself, ‘What the hell is going on?’ and convincing myself that this is not really happening to me.” A day after the beating, Chaddad recalls, Ali put his hands on his shoulder and comforted him, “‘Don’t worry, it’s part of my job. The pain will pass in a few days.’”

From this stage onward, Chaddad told his interrogators every last excruciating and paltry detail about his life: where he was from, what he did, where he grew up, where he traveled to, who his friends were, and with whom he had slept. This lasted through the following week, which happened to be Passover. Repeatedly interrogated about the same things by alternating investigators—he had nicknames for some of them—Chaddad was now questioned about his alleged Mossad rank and underwent cruel psychological mind games. Meanwhile, his captors kept reassuring him that his release was imminent.

Continue reading: Qaddafi, Sharansky, and a life-changing experience. Or view as a single page.

1 2 3View as single page
Print Email

The next time people in the West urge us to make concessions to the Palestinians just remember these are the people who we are dealing with.

Carl, trafficking in stereotypes about “these people” has never done Jews (or anyone else for that matter) much good.

Pamela J. says:

Everyone do a mitzpah today! If we all would, we could put an end to the craziness in the world today!
Our good, overcomes the uglyness of these types. Remember our Psalms: Whom shall I fear? Only Ha-Shem. Ha-Shem shsall deal with them all.

Pamela J.
kabbalah1818@yahoo.com

Great story told very well. Do we have a movie here?

Rebecca says:

the police there don’t arrest you because of any specific reason. They just do it because they can.” Qaddafi’s son Saif al-Islam has since publicly admitted that Hadad was actually not suspected of espionage

and so goes the muslim Arab mentality. Let’s hope that the Egyptian & Tunisian protests do have a positive effect and scare the hell out of other dictators to stop this nonsense. Remember the Bulgarian nurses who were raped and paid ransom for? They were probably hoping to get more money out the “rich Jews”

dani levi says:

I always wonder what the Arabs could do with their brains, if they didn’t waist them on all this paranoia? They’d actually get shit done. Like the rest of the world.

dani levi says:

the police there don’t arrest you because of any specific reason. They just do it because they can.” Qaddafi’s son Saif al-Islam has since publicly admitted that Hadad was actually not suspected of espionage

Why does a dog lick its balls?
Because it can.

James Pollock says:

Of course Palestinian prisoners are never abused in Israel’s detention centers. At least the relatively innocent ones aren’t. But they’re all guilty.

A remarkable story. Thank you.

Love the Muslim hospitality , its the BEST in the world.
From now on im only going to visit Muslim countries.

2 James Pollock
I hope it was a joke, just look at them when they released all fat and clean, Israeli prisons adhere to International standards, they revive education, food, TV, library and everything, Including family and red cross visits.
Unlike the IDF soldiers that imprisoned by hamas or hezbullah in sub human conditions, no visits and constant torture.

B”H February 17, 2011 You may wish to read my earnest efforts to portray the vision towards a secure freedom at http://www.englishquickly.com. I maintain no illusions about the serious threat brought about by the radicalism of Islamic populations from Lydia to Iraq, and I am shivering my timbers sitting here at the midpoint of the line between them. The military wise guys would do well to plan war strategy instead of the pursuit of fame they seek for their political aggrandizement. There is no two ways to stop the Iranian warship from getting to Syria, no life need be sacrificed – just blow up the Suez canal in a way that requires months of repair to enable utilization, and even pay compensation for the damage.

Facfax says:

So, why are Muslims so powerless?
Answer: Lack of education!
All we do is shout to Allah the whole day and blame everyone else for our multiple failures.
By: Dr. Farrukh Saleem
The writer is an Islamabad-based freelance columnist

Tablet editors: Once again, I appeal to you to clean up the comment threads. These racist, reactionary comments that you approve are lowering the standard of the site. I recommended this article on Twitter & the first reaction I’m getting is not ‘great article’ but rather ‘who are those insane commenters?’

Lee Price says:

Bravo, Ms. Goldman! I’m not going to recommend this to anyone… if possible I’ll find a report about the civilized, warm-hearted, compassionate Mr. Chadad that isn’t undercut by savage, vulgar comments profoundly disrespectful to the spirit of Judaism — and I’ll re-post that.

and I thought USSR collapsed…

H/Ramat-Gan/Israel says:

Lisa Goldman: These racist, reactionary comments blah blah blah

and I thought USSR collapsed…

Lisa Goldman: When it comes to self-delegitimizing, pro-Israel commenters are working 24/7. Go to Jerusalem Post and read any talkback-section, go to Pajamas media and read any comment thread on Israel. Open racism and islamophobia. Its quite strange that the pro-Israeli right mirrors the rhetoric of old-school antisemites. Sad and disturbing.

Aharon Rosner says:

If I can remember it was Qaddafi that had “bankrolled” the ransom for the European hostages that were taken from Sipadan, that money further went to the deep pockets of corrupt local officials and fuel more kidnap for ransom into a flourishing criminal industry that was the precursor of events by the so-called Islamic terrorist group Abu Sayyaf Group further deepened American involvement in the Philippines. What ever Qaddafi does is calculated genius at the expense of other people’s suffering. He indirectly supports terrorism and criminal activities. It would be good to know his time is running out.

Joseph Kessel says:

Who in their right minds ever wants to go back to these primitive, violent countries once you are safely living in a democratic state?
Canada is now trying to save the life of a citizen who returned to Iran,was arrested and now faces execution. Totally unnecessary to even contemplate returning , no matter what the reason is.

Leslie Fish says:

First, understand that “Arab” is not a race. Most Arabs are Semites, but not all of them are. There are tribes of Arabs with cream-pale skins, blue or green eyes and blond or red hair. There are also tribes that are distinctly Black. Disliking Arabs has nothing to do with racism.

“Arab” really refers to a general culture, and that culture is not a good one; it’s ferociously sexist, based on envy and spite, has a strong tendency toward religious fanaticism and bigotry, and believes in “phenomenalism” rather than science. It’s a culture that badly needs to change — or die — for the sake of the public peace.

–Leslie < Fish

I actually do love employing your organization. Your net layout is amazingly easy for the eye. You have got a great spot to shop. I genuinely enjoyed navigating in addition to ordering out of your site. It is incredibly, very simple to use and convenient. Great job over a fabulous website.

Great document! I’m all for it. The article really is helpful for me. Reading ones own article tends to make me joyful. At the same time frame, I might learn a lot more knowledge. Thanks quite definitely.

I’ve said that least 2115747 times. The problem this like that is they are just too compilcated for the average bird, if you know what I mean

I currently have read your article. It’s seriously helpful. We can benefit considerably from the idea. Fluent publishing style together with vivid thoughts make all of us readers love reading. I may share your current opinions having my mates.

I found it quiet interesting, hopefully you will keep posting such type of nice blogs.Keep sharing.thanks.

2000

Your comment may be no longer than 2,000 characters, approximately 400 words. HTML tags are not permitted, nor are more than two URLs per comment. We reserve the right to delete inappropriate comments.

Thank You!

Thank you for subscribing to the Tablet Magazine Daily Digest.
Please tell us about you.

Qaddafi’s Captive

When Israeli artist Rafram Chaddad visited Libya to document its once-thriving Jewish community, he was accused of espionage and put in jail. Now free, he tells of his five months in captivity.