Your email is not valid
Recipient's email is not valid
Submit Close

Your email has been sent.

Click here to send another

thescroll_header

Quds Day in Berlin

The convergence of paradoxes in Germany

Print Email
(Adam Chandler)

Malingerers in the shops on Kurfürstendamm Straße, one of West Berlin’s most chic boulevards, received a treat on Saturday afternoon when the pro-Palestinian (and very anti-Israel) Quds Day parade passed boisterously through. Out of the Hermès, Prada, Zegna, and the Hard Rock Café the tourists poured, visibly confused, at the sight of a political march and one counter-protest—separated by a heavy presence of German police trucks and officers (some in riot gear)—screaming at each other on the nicest day of the summer.

On one side were Quds Day marchers, numbering around 800-900 by some estimates, shouting the normal protest fare in unison: Freedom for Gaza, Freedom for Palestine, Intifada to victory, Zionism is fascism, Zionism is racism, Zionism is Nazism, Israelis are child-murderers.

Among the swell of Palestinian flags were also flags representing Turkey, Iran, Pakistan, and Lebanon. Signs declaring love for both the Ayatollah and the German poet Günter Grass were visible among the graphic pictures from various Israeli-Palestinian battles. There was also some anti-Semitic cartoons and some posters decrying German support of Israel. While they’d been mostly furled up earlier, a number of Hezbollah flags were now out and being flown to taunt the counter-protest on the other side of the street.

The counter-protest was a consortium of about 100 people including some far-left activists, a number of anti-fascists, some German Social Democrats, a few Israeli members of the socialist Zionist group Hashomer Hatzair, some members of a German gay alliance dressed in drag, and some anti-Islamist and anti-Iran activists. The group would eventually converge with a larger stationary pro-Israel rally, but along the Quds Day route, they waved Israeli flags and shouted back: Lang Lebe Israel (Long Live Israel), Smash anti-Semitism, Free Gaza from Hamas, Free Syria from Assad, Down with Fascism, Down with Iran.

Quds Day, known in some places as Jerusalem Day, which initially started in Iran in 1979, takes place on the last Friday of Ramadan. This year both gatherings in Tehran and Lebanon were marked by controversy with Iranian President Mahmoud Ahmadinejad calling again for Israel’s destruction and Hezbollah chief Hassan Nasrallah threatening to kill thousands of Israelis. In addition to Berlin, which has hosted a Quds Day rally annually since 1996, there are events yearly in cities like London, Paris, and Toronto.

I spoke to a number of participants on all sides: some pro-Israel activists of the far left, a member of Iran’s Green Party, a supporter of the Iranian regime, a pro-Assad neo-Nazi, a few Israelis living in Berlin, and a few German bystanders. All of them helped to give texture to the paradoxical/fascinating/worrisome picture of the German attitude toward Israel (which one could spend years studying) as well as the European tolerance with regard to Hezbollah and the fascinating anomaly that is a pro-Israel far-left.

In the coming days, I’ll have some posts from these conversations. Stay tuned.

Earlier: Günter Grass’ Stupid Poem About Israel and Iran
Nasrallah threatens to turn Israeli lives into hell [TDS]

Print Email
PhillipNagle says:

It is not suprising as Grand Mufti of Jerusalem and his Islamist sopporters were allies of Hitler. This is just a way for the Nazis to parade without being Nazis. Though from the description of some of the opposition, let me say I’m glad I’m not in Berlin where I would have to choose sides.

What a culture, that sets aside a day to proclaim hate. Who else does such a thing!? With all of the documented wrongs perpetrated against Jews in ancient and recent times, and the corresponding days of remembrance, it would be understandable for Jews/Israelis responded with hate. But in Jewish culture, there is nothing to parallel this level of discourse, this hate, this vitriol. If there were some Jews to behave this way, many more Jewish voices would be the first to speak out against them. Nasrallah, an Arab leader, proud of the fact that he can kill thousands? Ahmedinejad vowing to destroy Israel and “Zionism” (hint: Zionists=Jews)?

Romney WAS right. It’s all about culture. And no, it’s not racist to say that, either. In fact, it’s racist NOT to say that. As long as society clings to the bigotry of low expectations and tolerate these hatefests, we perpetuate (and foster) this disgusting behavior.

So. An “open debate” about Israel is needed. Sure. Happy to do so. In fact, we’ve been “debating” Israel ad nauseum. The REAL question is “Where’s the “open debate” about the Palestinians?” Where is the wide range of opinion on THAT topic in the marketplace of ideas? The answer is, there isn’t any. And that’s because dissent is dealt with swiftly and in many cases brutally, in the region, and in the West, it’s considered not politically correct to do so. So, I reiterate. It’s about culture.

There’s Haman and Amalek. We go on on Passover about how it would have been enough if our enemies had all been destroyed, but…

Sure, that’s a private matter, and you don’t see us stirring up anti-German or anti-Arab protests, but it’s not as if there’s NO parallel.

2000

Your comment may be no longer than 2,000 characters, approximately 400 words. HTML tags are not permitted, nor are more than two URLs per comment. We reserve the right to delete inappropriate comments.

Thank You!

Thank you for subscribing to the Tablet Magazine Daily Digest.
Please tell us about you.

Quds Day in Berlin

The convergence of paradoxes in Germany

More on Tablet:

Seattle’s Sephardi Jews Brought Us Starbucks: Now They’re Trying To Bring Back Ladino

By Emily K. Alhadeff — Seven decades ago, the Jews of Rhodes were sent to Auschwitz. Now some descendants are preserving a culture nearly lost.