Your email is not valid
Recipient's email is not valid
Submit Close

Your email has been sent.

Click here to send another

thescroll_header

Can You Spot the Reuters Mistake Here?

Your Hamas, history, and Arab Peace Initiative lesson for the day

Print Email
Ismail Haniyeh(AFP)

Today, Reuters is reporting that Hamas is not a fan of the revamped Arab Peace Initiative, which made waves this week when it was put forth by the Qatari prime minister.

In a statement today, Hamas leader Ismail Haniyeh channeled Jay-Z by essentially saying that we must not let outsiders violate our blocks. (Of course, if Qatar wants to pledge hundreds of millions of dollars to reconstruction in Gaza, you know, no problem.)

In reporting the statement, Reuters placed Haniyeh’s quote and context thusly:

“The so-called new Arab initiative is rejected by our people, by our nation and no one can accept it,” said Haniyeh, prime minister of the Hamas government in the coastal enclave.

“The initiative contains numerous dangers to our people in the occupied land of 1967, 1948 and to our people in exile.”

He was referring to the partition of British-mandate Palestine in 1948 when the United Nations voted to divide the territory into a Jewish state and an Arab state, and to the 1967 war when Israel captured the West Bank, East Jerusalem and Gaza.

There is a mistake here, which if you can’t spot yourself, I’ll explain after the break here.

***

The article does get it right in explaining that Hamas rejects Israel’s right to exist and that Hamas claims all land between the river and the sea to be Palestinian. But in the quote above, Haniyeh wasn’t referring to the “partition of British-mandate Palestine in 1948 when the United Nations voted to divide the territory into a Jewish state and an Arab state” when he said he talked about the occupied land of 1948.

It’s a pretty basic fact that the vote on UN Resolution 181–the Partition Plan–took place in November 1947. What Haniyeh was bemoaning was the Israeli War of Independence, which started in 1948 after the Arabs rejected the UN partition plan, Israel declared independence, and seven Arab nations attacked.

I’m not sure you can call this a subtle mistake, but it’s an important one because it was the War of Independence (or in Haniyeh-ese “The Nakba”) that brought Israel into the world. 65 years later, Israel exists and Hamas refuses to accept its existence. The Hamas denial of this very real, generations-old fact–and all rejectionism for that matter–is a major reason why proposals like the Arab Peace Initiative and numerous Israeli proposals and overtures have not produced lasting peace.

Hamas Rebuffs Arabs for Softening Israeli-Palestinian Peace Plan [Reuters]

Print Email
Jack Estes says:

Right on! The Arabs forget that they lost the war that they started. Therefore, Israel should claim ALL of the territory, since Hammas continues to attack; this is not acceptable in ANY context. Of course, being a Christian, I see that Israel has had since the time of Moses to inhabit and defend their territory, as any nation MUST have defensible borders — but the ancient leaders seen not to know this when they separated into Judah and Israel. Now, the peoples of Ancient Israel became the “Ten Lost Tribes”, but in fact became Europeans and settled America, following the Jewish Prophet Jesus. So, i have a question that has been in my mind for 60 years: “What is it about Jewish Jesus’ teachings that Israel rejects?” — Jack Charles Estes. I am an oil industry Hall of Fame Scientist and my website is http://www.EDTIdrilling.com

SANDYSEARCH says:

Not even a blade of grass from the land should be given to the Palestinians! ITS THE LAND OF ISRAEL WORLD!!! HAVE YOU FORGOTTEN! Abraham – Isaac – Jacob – Twelve tribes led out of Egypt by Moses – Joshua! Sion the city of David! Jerusalem is the capital of Israel. If the Jews do not have the right to all of the land they do not have the right to any of the land!

ginzy1 says:

great comment!

oaklandj says:

Take your mishegas elsewhere, like a Christian site. Please.

2000

Your comment may be no longer than 2,000 characters, approximately 400 words. HTML tags are not permitted, nor are more than two URLs per comment. We reserve the right to delete inappropriate comments.

Thank You!

Thank you for subscribing to the Tablet Magazine Daily Digest.
Please tell us about you.

Can You Spot the Reuters Mistake Here?

Your Hamas, history, and Arab Peace Initiative lesson for the day

More on Tablet:

Why I’m Unsubscribing to the New York Times

By Richard A. Block — Leading Reform rabbi cites newspaper’s one-sided coverage of Gaza war