Your email is not valid
Recipient's email is not valid
Submit Close

Your email has been sent.

Click here to send another

thescroll_header

The Top 10 Jewish-American Athletes

Why now? Why not now?

Print Email
Sandy Koufax holding one ball for each of his no-hitters.(Jewish Journal)

Honorable Mention: Amar’e Stoudemire

10. Kerri Strug
9. Al Rosen
8. Sarah Hughes
7. Barney Ross
6. Benny Leonard
5. Dolph Schayes
4. Sid Luckman
3. Mark Spitz
2. Hank Greenberg
1. Sandy Koufax

Print Email

The shocking and bizarre omission of Jose Bautista leads to one important question, why not?

Lenny Krayzelburg?

Ken Donow says:

As much as it galls me to say it, I think Kevin Youkilis deserves a spot. He’s being doing it consistently enough for long enough.

Tony Oliva

Steven Brown says:

Youk!!!!!!!Youk!!!! Youk!!!!

Shawn Green

Steve Pulvers says:

Max Siebald 2009 Teewarton winner as the top collegiate lacrosse player from Cornell . One of the stars of the USA national team that just won the world championship in the UK. Called a “beast” by the top coach in the game. About 6’2″ 225lbs. and a 4.4 in the 60. Most spectacular play was when carrying the ball a big Syracuse defender came up to stop him. Max just ran over him,decleated the guy knocking him back over 5 yards! Also has a shot timed at 110 mph. Also heavily recruited for football.

Les Miller says:

Kerri Strug??? How about Sid Gilman; albeit a coach, but also a profound innovator in football and a good Jew, to boot.

Doc L says:

There are a few Ice Hockey players both currently, Steven Weiss and Ryan Kessler, and from the past Josef Baranack. What about the heavy weight from Turnersville, NJ, Rossman?

WSCohen says:

What about Max Baer ?

Marc Tracy says:

Sid Gilman played, but his influence was as a coach, and I was going athletes. Once you open the coaching door, you have to have Auerbach and Holzman, too, and arguably Larry Brown. Kerri Strug, on the other hand, heroically helped the U.S. win a Gold Medal.

As for Baer, my understanding is that it was mostly schtick: He may have had some Jewish blood, but only identified as Jewish for marketing purposes. anyway would still take leonard and Ross over him.

She didn’t heroically “help,” she heroically “won.” No need to hedge.
Who are the top ten non-American Jewish athletes? Is it true that Yao Ming is the last living descendant of the Kaifeng Rebbe?

AZZ,

Yao Ming is the last living descendant but only through his father. His mother isn’t Jewish. He’s kind of like the Chinese Ian Kinsler. They both are professional athletes who play in Texas, have Jewish fathers and suffer from foot injuries.

Richard Friedman says:

What about Benny Friedman. He’s only in the NFL Hall of Fame!

Mike Shapiro says:

Way too NYC & professional centered. I actually remember when you could gain fame as an amateur athlete and not become a significant pro.

A. Lennie Rosenbluth
B. Reds Auerbach (point guard, Geo. Washington Univ….Whole starting five was TEP)
C. Youk (maybe a victim of Ashkenazic centeredness)
D. Lip Pike
E. Special consideration for:
1. Moe Berg – For obvious reasons
2. Al Schact – Clown prince of baseball

Larry says:

These type of lists are relevant to what?
All a bunch of bull.
Might as well add Sidney Franklin.

Garrett Wittels? He’s got a 56-game hitting streak heading into next year’s NCAA season, could overtake Robin Ventura as the longest streak in college history at 58 next year.
http://www.jta.org/news/article/2010/07/06/2739929/dimaggio-koufax-wittels

Holly Martins says:

I vote for Barak Obama. He threw out the first pitch at last years All-Star game. For this he also deserves the Cy Young award.

As long as “The Big Jew” is number one,all is right with the list…

Packers lineman Buckets Goldenberg: http://www.packershalloffame.org/index.php?option=com_content&task=view&id=117&Itemid=47

I can also attest to the fine kugel served at his restaurant.

Peter Medard says:

Where is MARTY Glickman, the equal of Sid Luckman in the 30′s ?

BH in Iowa says:

More Honorable Mentions:

Bill Goldberg as a foolball player for the Georgia Bulldogs and in the NFL.

Two Israelis who play/ed basketball in the US:

Omri Caspi – Scaramento Kings

Nadav Henefeld – UConn Huskies

stanley schweiger says:

Dolph Schayes of DeWitt Clinton HS, NYU, and the Syracuse Nationals has been my sports hero since I was 11 years old. That’s 57 years & counting! No one in NBA history worked harder or played tougher than #4!

Mike Romanov says:

I see one name missing who should be there.

Nat Holman, member of the Original (NY) Celtics, BBall Coach at CCNY for forty or so years, having a winning record and for at least the years 1919 up to 1950, playing the best college teams in America. Voted the third-best basketball player of the first half of the 20th century.

1n 1950, his CCNY team won the National Invitation Tournament (NIT) at Madison Square Garden, then the most prestigious tournament in the USA, AND the NCAA Tournament. CCNY was the only college team ever to do that. A few years later, When the NCAA decided not to permit NIT teams to also play in the NCAA tourney, winning that double no longer became a possibility. It was common to see the teams invited to the NIT also playing in the NCAA Tournament. In 1950, CCNY beat Bradley University in the championship game of both tournaments. Holman is a member of the Naismith Basketball Hall of Fame.

Naismith deserves inclusion in the top ten list both as an athlete and as a coach.

Nat Holman Nat Holman Nat Holman!

Amar’e Stoudemire,Support!Support!Support!

ozzie says:

rudy larusso. gail goodrich,ryan braun,barny ross, max zaslovsky

Rod Carew!

Malcolm Peskoff says:

Ruben Amaro Jr. is Jewish. He played for the Phillies at SS, and is now the GM, and possible one of the owners.
His mother was Jewish.

Not about the subject, just small advise here. Verify your akismet or plug akismet , yours is damaged to pieces. You will get horrible amounts of unsolicited mail for those who wont repair it.

When I originally commented I clicked the -Notify me when new surveys are added- checkbox now each time a comment is added I recieve four emails sticking with the same comment. Possibly there is that is you can eliminate me from that service? Thanks!

Nice read, I just passed this onto a friend who was doing some research on thatAnd he just bought me lunch because I found it for him smile Thus let me rephrase that: Thanks for lunch!

Youkilis,Bautista,and Boudreau should certainly have been included.There was also Larry Zeidel and Mathew Schneider of NHL hockey fame.Youkilis is still a regular every day player in the Major league.There are other ball players presently playing or recently retired.

Bautista is a major present every day home run hitter and like Youkilis an every day player Boudreau and the hockey players are all retired.

Shawn Green is also retired in recent years as a major league baseball player,and Amare Stoudamire is still playing pro basketball with the N.Y. Knicks. There were or still are athletes in lesser sports such as bowling and tennis where some Jews excelled. Fencing always had a number of Jewish stars as did the Soviets in hockey. Wikipedia would have many of these little known Jews listed.There was a female Canadian track star whose name eludes me..

There are still a number of Jews presently playing pro baseball even today aside from Youkilis and Bautista. Wikipedia would have all or most of them listed.

roccothegreat says:

Red Auerbach, one of the most successful NBA coaches and general managers in history.

roccothegreat says:

Rosenbluth was a great scorer. Helms Foundation named him player of the year over Wilt Chamberlain. That is saying something.

2000

Your comment may be no longer than 2,000 characters, approximately 400 words. HTML tags are not permitted, nor are more than two URLs per comment. We reserve the right to delete inappropriate comments.

Thank You!

Thank you for subscribing to the Tablet Magazine Daily Digest.
Please tell us about you.

The Top 10 Jewish-American Athletes

Why now? Why not now?

More on Tablet:

How To Say You’re Sorry

By Marjorie Ingall — As Yom Kippur approaches, I’ll share what I’ve learned about how to apologize—and how not to