Your email is not valid
Recipient's email is not valid
Submit Close

Your email has been sent.

Click here to send another

thescroll_header

Israeli Airport Security, All the Rage

And why it doesn’t completely translate

Print Email
The day before Thanksgiving at LaGuardia Airport.(Stan Honda/AFP/Getty Images)

Though it has since died down, in the weeks before Thanksgiving few stories were bigger than the Transportation Security Administration’s alleged new, overly intrusive airport inspections (media columnist David Carr explained yesterday why the meme resonated so much). If the United States was the Bad Guy—bulky, unnecessary, and despicable, embodied in the viral video by the security agent who aggressively patted down the three-year-old—then the Good Guy was Israeli airport security, which famously protects an ostensibly far more endangered populace, and does so with a certain flair (remember how after 9/11 you heard that the only airline that still served their meals with metal utensils was El Al?).

Dutifully, the Washington Post consulted an Israeli security expert, who dutifully informed us that using intelligence-like security techniques such as profiling and targeted inspections and questioning is faster, less intrusive (for most), and more effective than the American way. We also learned that Israel self-consciously sees security expertise as one of its most promising exports. The problem, arguably, as Post columnist Dana Milbank reported, is that Israel’s way is far more expensive: Israel spends $56.75 per passenger, the United States spends $6.93 per passenger—figures that probably reflect the geometrically larger scale the U.S. operates with, but only in part. Which doesn’t mean Israel has no wisdom to offer, but that their methods are only applicable to a certain extent.

Which doesn’t mean they’re not going to make fun of us!

Israeli Air Security Experts Insist Their Methods Better Than U.S. [WP]
Israeli Firms See a Global Market for their Anti-Terrorism Know-How [LAT]
Why The Israeli Security Model Can’t Work for the U.S. [WP]
Earlier: Why Israel’s Airport Security Will Remain Only Israel’s

Print Email
edward rosen says:

If you teach your secrets to others , they will figure out how to obviate it.However,if you only teach part of the secret it may take longer to find openings.but the ultimate result will be the same.I do not believe Israel will allow or chance giving information that could eventually endanger it.

Morris Abadi (Sao Paulo/Brazil) says:

Security wich does not generate inconvenience, is a bad security. Period.

Morris Abadi (Sao Paulo/Brazil) says:

And if all the security technology is known by anyone, it is not secure anymore.

2000

Your comment may be no longer than 2,000 characters, approximately 400 words. HTML tags are not permitted, nor are more than two URLs per comment. We reserve the right to delete inappropriate comments.

Thank You!

Thank you for subscribing to the Tablet Magazine Daily Digest.
Please tell us about you.

Israeli Airport Security, All the Rage

And why it doesn’t completely translate

More on Tablet:

Our Unexpected Passover Guest

By Rebecca Klempner — Nobody expected my grandfather to show up at my apartment for Passover—two months after he died