Your email is not valid
Recipient's email is not valid
Submit Close

Your email has been sent.

Click here to send another

thescroll_header

‘Talmud, Index of’

Why 2011 brings history’s first complete register of the body of Jewish law

Print Email
A page from the Talmud.(Barak-Janah/Flickr)

Perhaps the most fascinating thing about the first-ever index to the great, intricate body of Jewish law, the Talmud—whose existence and provenance was reported yesterday by Joseph Berger in the New York Times—isn’t who made it. Yes, it’s remarkable that HaMafteach (“the Key”), the 30,000-plus entry index to the 63-volume Talmud (yours in Hebrew or English for less than $30!) is the handiwork not of an esteemed committee of rabbis who worked on it for decades, full-time, but of one Daniel Retter, an immigration attorney from the Bronx. What’s absolutely incredible is that nobody has ever done it before. The Talmud was definitively compiled in 540, and give or take movable type, word processing, and a few other innovations, the same technology Retter used to create his defiantly non-hyperlinked tome has been available to generations of sages. (And on the other hand you can read the Talmud on your iPad.) Yet this is the only one of its kind.

This new advance—which has received the blessing even of eminent rabbis—seems to me a function of the Jews’ current status as well as of the status of humanity’s collective consciousness. “The Talmud was written in exile, and it was the thread that kept Jews together,” Retter says in the article. “It was a book that was to be transmitted orally from father to son.” It’s an insightful observation: The Talmud was about more than the laws of the Jews; it was itself an instrument of the propagation of the Jews, an agreed-upon device for forcing Jews to constantly think about and study Judaism. But in the Jews’ postmodern state, with Diaspora eliminated either via aliyah or the comfortable blend of assimilation and domesticity most American Jews would claim, the Talmud has lost that function, and so an index—a way to make studying Talmud easier—no longer seems at cross-purposes with one aspect of the Talmud’s existence.

And while the index itself demands no computer, the efficiencies and conveniences of advanced computing have conditioned us to expect the ease and the speed that the index enables. The article’s kicker, predictably, relays the information that if you find errors in the index, email errorsandcomments@hamafteach.org. Clearly the index isn’t unrelated to the Internet. But it’s still wonderful that the thing itself is totally old-school.

Speaking of which, this isn’t the Times’ most-emailed article? What are you people waiting for?

After 1,500 Years, an Index to the Talmud’s Labyrinths, With Roots in the Bronx [NYT]

Print Email
Stephan Pickering/Chofetz Chay says:

Shalom & Boker tov…kol tuv uv’racha…may you be blessed with all that is good, Daniel Retter…now, we need an index to the major texts of Merkavah/Hekhalot, the Zohar…Stephan Pickering / Chofetz Chayim ben-Avraham
Santa Cruz, Karloffornia

Other indexes have been written to the Talmud, this is just the most recent one. See the comments to the post at my blog: http://bit.ly/tpLtKy.

While this book is certainly an impressive accomplishment, it most certainly is not the first of its kind. The Soncino Talmud’s final volume, called “Index” appropriately enough, is the same thing and has existed for decades. And it’s on sale!
http://www.soncino.com/product_info.php/cPath/22/products_id/33?osCsid=ddf6d65c5a3ca24d348449fbb6131735

2000

Your comment may be no longer than 2,000 characters, approximately 400 words. HTML tags are not permitted, nor are more than two URLs per comment. We reserve the right to delete inappropriate comments.

Thank You!

Thank you for subscribing to the Tablet Magazine Daily Digest.
Please tell us about you.

‘Talmud, Index of’

Why 2011 brings history’s first complete register of the body of Jewish law

More on Tablet:

Italian Politician’s Primo Levi Parody Panned

By Stephanie Butnick — Beppe Grillo under fire for anti-government poem based on ‘If This Is a Man’