This week on the show: Nazis, Taylor Swift, and cats—the Unorthodox trifecta.

Our Jewish guest is Chicago native Jeff Aeder, who founded the online Jewish Baseball Museum. The Cubs fan tells us about some lesser-known Jewish figures throughout America’s national pastime, why he thinks we need an institution dedicated to Jews in baseball, and when we can expect a brick-and-mortar museum.

Our Gentile of the Week is Carrie Poppy—writer, actress, and co-host of the podcast Oh No Ross and Carrie, which investigates fringe science and religious groups (there’s a seven-part Scientology series) and alternative medicine. She tells us about the wackiest movement she’s encountered and what she thinks draws people to these kinds of groups. She also brings a bunch of very good questions about Judaism—including, naturally, Kabbalah.

We love to hear from you! Send comments, questions, and complaints to We’ll share our favorites on air.

This episode of Unorthodox is brought to you by Harry’s. Stop overpaying for a great shave. Go to and enter the code UNORTHODOX at checkout for $5 off your first order.