Ask Unorthodox: Vegan Torah?
Pondering an alternative to animal-derived parchment for a Torah scroll
Unorthodox, the world’s leading Jewish podcast, takes questions from its listeners about all aspects of Jewish life, from the religiously profound to the utterly inconsequential. Every week, we discuss one of these questions in “Ask Unorthodox.” If you have a question, please send it to [email protected].
Writing on our Facebook group, listener Laura came to us with this intriguing question: “Is it possible/kosher to write a vegan Torah? That is, write the scroll on non–animal-derived parchment?” What a fabulous question! Given the attention in Judaism over the past couple of decades to animal rights and ecology, we were surprised that we had never thought of this. All the discussion of ethical farming practices and more humane shechita, and nary a discussion of making a Torah that isn’t soaked in the blood of a suffering sheep.
We turned to Rabbi Gil Student—mainly because we like his last name so much, but also because of his fab blog Torah Musings—and he replied promptly and authoritatively. “For sure not,” he instructed, in what we imagine over email to be a resonant baritone, kindly, firm, and not unsexy. “A Torah scroll must be written specifically on the skin of kosher animals.” He directed us to Yosef Karo’s definitive 16th century compendium of Jewish law, Shulchan Aruch (Yoreh De’ah 271:1). “If we could,” he added, “we would use paper, which is much cheaper.” And easier on the sheep.
But the discussion didn’t end there (does it ever?). Our Tablet colleague Menachem Butler, intrigued by the question, sent along a 2003 scholarly article that discussed the possibility that Torah scrolls could be silk-screened, which would honor the requirement that every letter be written by a qualified sofer, or scribe, while greatly reducing the cost of a full scroll. If the sofer created the stencils and forced the ink through the screen, he would be writing the scroll. The halakhic condemnation around this proposal was harsh but interesting, and the sources cited included Maimonides’ discussion of whether illiterate witnesses may sign their names with spittle.
The point is, the rules around the manufacture of a Torah scroll are being contested in all sorts of ways, so why not invoke the conversation about the treatment of animals? For example, what if we can use the technology that’s giving us test-tube-grown meat to give us test-tube hides? Some Orthodox rabbis would object, but that’s what modern Orthodoxy is for. Or Conservative Judaism. Or Renewal. You’d get buy-in somewhere.
Meanwhile, the Facebook conversation was not over. Our listener Lindsay responded to Laura with a pro-animal concern of her own. “I’ve been considering getting a mezuza,” Lindsay wrote, “but I’ve read that it’s supposed to be parchment of animal hide, and I’d rather not.” Indeed, the parchment is supposed to be animal hide. But take it from us: The animals who sacrifice a mere couple square inches of hide so that you can proudly mark your home as a Jew, Lindsay, are glad to help.
If you have a question send it to us on a parchment postcard. Or write to us at [email protected]. To get the Unorthodox podcast, visit iTunes here, or use your favorite app.
Unorthodox is a smart, fresh, fun weekly take on Jewish news and culture hosted by Mark Oppenheimer, Stephanie Butnick, and Liel Leibovitz. You can listen to individual episodes here or subscribe on iTunes.
- UnorthodoxShaken, Not SchnorredEp. 405: Interviews with Brett Gelman, Zibby Owens, and The Sporkful’s Dan Pashman, plus news of a Jewish James BondMarch 28, 2024
- UnorthodoxA Beautifully Jewish ShabbatEp. 404: Dishing on the day of rest with cookbook author Adeena Sussman and Judaica designer Micaela Ezra; plus a taste of Tablet’s new parsha podcastMarch 21, 2024
- UnorthodoxIrrefutably JewishEp. 403: Phil Rosenthal on writing a children’s book with his daughter Lily; a classical Jewish school in New York City; Oscar meshugas; and moreMarch 14, 2024
- UnorthodoxSpiritual Swear JarEp. 402: Eylon Levy on crafting Israel’s message; Andrew Goldberg on Armenia; plus Joshua Malina, pickleball icon March 7, 2024
- UnorthodoxWe Can HelpEp. 401: AJC CEO Ted Deutch on antisemitism in America, a visit to a Brooklyn school welcoming Ukrainian refugees, our new favorite children’s book, and a visit from Kosha DillzFebruary 22, 2024
- UnorthodoxKosher FiestaEp. 400: Dr. Phil on his new TV network; plus a look at how Israel’s Maaleh Film School is pivoting post-Oct. 7; and a listener question about tablewareFebruary 15, 2024
- UnorthodoxSlam DunkEp. 399: NBA All-Star Allan Houston’s new faith initiative, and revisiting the Michael Milken trialFebruary 8, 2024
- UnorthodoxHigher GroundEp. 398: Jewish actress Jamie-Lynn Sigler on 25 years since ‘The Sopranos,’ plus a visit to try Israel’s best hummus dishFebruary 1, 2024
- UnorthodoxThings RememberedEp. 397: Uncovering a tale of complicity and justice, sonic studies, and a little red dress for International Holocaust Remembrance Day January 25, 2024
- Unorthodox100 DaysEp. 396: Marking a grim milestone since the Oct. 7 Hamas massacre and honoring the hostages still held in GazaJanuary 18, 2024
- UnorthodoxFirst DraftsEp. 395: Kicking off 2024 with comedian Moshe KasherJanuary 11, 2024
- UnorthodoxHeading NorthEp. 394: A visit to Jewish Montreal; Gadi Taub on ‘Israel Update’; getting Kafkaesque at the National Library of IsraelDecember 28, 2023
- UnorthodoxUnorthodox in IsraelStories recorded on the ground from a country mourning, healing, and coming togetherDecember 18, 2023
- UnorthodoxMidnight OilEp. 393: Nine stories for HanukkahDecember 14, 2023
- UnorthodoxShine BrightEp. 392: Celebrating the beauty of Hanukkah with Jonathan Adler, Homegrown Kosher, and moreDecember 7, 2023
- UnorthodoxEveryday HeroesEp. 391: Bernard-Henri Lévy’s new film about Ukraine, and Brooke Eby on raising awareness about ALSNovember 30, 2023
- UnorthodoxSitting TogetherEp. 390: A Beautifully Jewish Thanksgiving, featuring an iconic folding chair and a conversation with knitwear designer Inbal GrossNovember 22, 2023
- UnorthodoxDark Times, Bright LightsEp. 389: Reporting from the March for Israel in Washington, D.C.; Etgar Keret’s writer’s block; LeElle Slifer on advocating for her kidnapped Israeli cousins; and Tablet’s Hanukkah BazaarNovember 16, 2023