Your email is not valid
Recipient's email is not valid
Submit Close

Your email has been sent.

Click here to send another

Anti-Anti-Semitism

World Without Nazism is a Kremlin-flavored Anti-Defamation League for the post-Soviet realm—but is it good for Jews?

Print Email
Boris Shpigel, far left, speaking at the World Without Nazism conference. (World Congress of Russian Jewry)
Related Content

The Crime of Surviving

By arguing that Nazi and Soviet crimes are equal, Lithuania is airbrushing the Holocaust out of its history

Satellite of Hate

In Kyrgyzstan, anti-Semitism erupts in the wake of the president’s ouster

A History of Violence

It wasn’t just a case of bullying when a 16-year-old Jewish boy was beaten up in a small German town where hate runs deep

On a jetlagged June morning in downtown Kiev, I briefly but completely lost my mind.

Three hundred of us had been flown in for the founding conference of a new Moscow-based watchdog organization, World Without Nazism. For the event’s kick-off, conference participants gathered in a sun-dappled Vichnoyi Slavy Park, home to the city’s Monument of Eternal Glory at the Grave of the Unknown Soldier. We were each handed a red carnation, arranged in parade formation, and led 100 yards toward a massive obelisk memorial. My moment of supreme disorientation occurred just a few steps into the procession, when from behind the bushes came a jolting martial thunder: Previously unseen Brezhnev-era trucks topped with what looked like air-raid sirens had begun blasting the opening chords of “People, Awake!” a 1941 hit from the back catalog of the Red Army Choir. After we reached the obelisk, the very loud Soviet anthem gave way to another, and then another.

“We’ll come back with victory!” promised the all-male choir. “The Red Army is the strongest!”

Under this siege of Soviet orchestral swells, I struggled to remember my purpose in Kiev. Was I here for a conference on combating anti-Semitism? Or had I been cast in a shitty remake of Battle at Kursk?

A similar schizophrenia defined the rest of the inaugural conference of World Without Nazism (WWN), a new initiative from the World Congress of Russian Jewry and its president, the Kremlin-connected mini-oligarch Boris Shpigel. On the opening morning of proceedings, the event distinguished itself by becoming what might be the only conference to receive official letters of support from both Hillary Clinton and the autonomous government of South Ossetia. At the podium, speakers spoke of trivialization and denial, though it was not always clear whether they were referring to the Holocaust, or the decisive sacrifice of millions of Red Army soldiers. At the Hotel Prezidente, where the conference was taking place, whores prowled the muzak-cursed lobby as aggressively as they would have 15 years ago.

The most potent symbol of this schizophrenia is also its primary source. While the new organization aspires to global influence and credibility—a kind of Moscow-based Anti-Defamation League that would partner with the European Union and the United Nations—its founding president and public face is a man whose fortunes depend in part on framing Jewish interests to fit the view from the Kremlin.

Boris Shpigel is a bald, round man who looks older than his 57 years and is given to slumping in his seat. He emerged early in the Boris Yeltsin era. Like others who prospered during the 1990s, he anticipated the coming curve and founded the pharmaceuticals firm Biotek shortly before the dissolution of the Soviet Union. By the time Vladimir Putin assumed power, Shpigel had grown his firm from a small research outfit south of Moscow to a major producer dominant in more than 70 markets across the Eurasian expanse. In 2002, he helped found and lead the Party of Russia’s Rebirth, a centrist social-democratic party that enjoyed the blessing of Mikhail Gorbachev (and, thought some, the Kremlin, which had been known to fund center-left parties designed to siphon off support from the Communists). By the time Shpigel was elected president of the World Congress of Russian Jewry in 2007, he was a major player at the nexus of business, diplomacy, and culture among Russia, Israel, and the Russian-speaking Jewish Diaspora. Today, as a Duma member, Shpigel sits on committees that handle everything from public institutions to the funding of science, culture, education, and health care.

Concerns over coziness with the Kremlin have dogged WWN’s parent organization, the World Congress of Russian Jewry. When it was founded in 2002 as an outgrowth of the Lubavitch-led Federation of Jewish Communities of the CIS, some worried the WCRJ was too intertwined with the Russian government to be an effective advocate. Since assuming the WCRJ presidency, Shpigel has only helped validate these concerns. During Russia’s conflict with Georgia over South Ossetia in the summer 2008, Shpigel issued an overheated statement on WCRJ letterhead calling for a tribunal to investigate what he termed acts of “genocide” and “ethnic cleansing” committed by the Georgian military. Though the casual use of such language is anathema to responsible Jewish leadership, Shpigel did not hesitate to echo the Kremlin’s bombast. It was left to Shpigel’s deputy at the Congress, Israeli Knesset Member Ze’ev Elkin, to dial back the statement. The role of the WCRJ, an exasperated Elkin told Haaretz, is to worry about the well-being of Jews worldwide, not get involved in “geo-political conflicts.”

Yet viewed from Moscow, the growth of far-right activity in the former Eastern bloc is hard to disentangle from geo-politics. This is especially true when this activity bubbles up behind NATO lines, embodied by groups espousing anti-Russian and anti-Semitic rhetoric. WWN’s early fire has been directed toward the Baltics, where attacks on Soviet war monuments are increasingly accompanied by efforts to celebrate the Nazis (as well as their local collaborators) and edit the history of the Holocaust. In July, WWN’s first official statement targeted a decision by Riga’s Administrative Court to sanction a public demonstration honoring the Nazi occupation government. WWN was quick and correct to publicize and condemn the decision. But its letter contained a whiff of Kremlin anti-Western boilerplate, blaming EU leniency for the rise of far-right nationalism in the region.

That the European Union has indeed failed to rigorously enforce laws on extremism and denial does not change the fact that the WWN’s condemnations, if they are to be taken seriously, must be matched by efforts to shame authorities in Russia itself, which is home to a growing culture of far-right street violence targeting Jews, activists, and, especially, migrant workers from Central Asia. Notably, WWN was silent in late August when 100 skinheads attacked a concert in the central Russian city of Miass, resulting in dozens of injuries and the death of a 14-year-old girl. (The organization did, however, find time in August to issue a statement in opposition to Manhattan’s Park51 development, aka the “Ground Zero Mosque.”)

One speaker in Kiev publicly addressed these issues and urged the new organization to recognize the historical crimes of communism, even as it challenges official efforts in Eastern Europe to equate and conflate those crimes with those of the Nazis. That speaker was Dovid Katz, a former professor at the University of Vilnius (and Tablet contributor) and the curator of HolocaustInTheBaltics.com. “While we reject the theories of ‘equivalence’ of Nazi and Soviet crimes,” said Katz, “we must be careful never to join those who would deny or mitigate or trivialize the enormous crimes committed by Stalinism and Soviet domination of many lands and peoples against their will.”

“It is also very important that our movement has a democratic Western atmosphere,” he continued. “It must never be seen to be in any way subservient to today’s Russian area politics. We should be meeting in Amsterdam, London, and Paris, not just Kiev, Moscow, and Minsk.”

Regardless of where it holds future meetings, and however compromised by Kremlin ties it may be, WWN hardly lacks for urgent work. As the multinational cast of speakers in Kiev made clear, there is a rising “brown tide” in Eastern Europe and throughout the continent. Well-organized neo-fascist political movements are on the march in Hungary and Italy. In the Baltics, monuments to the Holocaust are being removed and the Nazi occupations publicly glorified. Far-right thugs and activists prowl the streets, march on capitals, speak in universities, and organize online, often in flagrant violation of the law.

If World Without Nazism is to join the fight against these developments, it must overcome suspicions that it is little more than just a PR operation for the Russian foreign ministry. Here’s hoping that it does.

Alexander Zaitchik, a writer living in Brooklyn, is the author of Common Nonsense: Glenn Beck and the Triumph of Ignorance.

Print Email

Not good for the Jews. When organizations such as ADL and WWN lack credibility, they are not good for the Jews.

naomi fishman says:

How did the WWN come up with name?

How do you understand the rise of the right?

Don’t forget: it was Soviet Union (Kremlin) and Red Army soldiers that saved Jews of Europe from annihilation. Just a reminder.

The ADL is not good for the Jews either…

Jews should stop looking for boogeymen in Europe and instead focus on their real anti-Semitic neighbors who call for the destruction of Israel. I don’t think that there are any nations today in Europe who hate Jews, even though there may be some that may, the same way that Israel’s neighbors do, especially the Iranians, who want to see the total destruction of Israel. Exagerating so called anti-Semitism in Europe and painting nations as anti-Semitic just causes people to lose any sympathy that they may have for Israel. Moreover, it is time for the Jews to admit to their complicity in Soviet atrocities that they committed in collaboration with the Russians during the Soviet Russian occupation in Eastern Europe. The infamous Soviet Jew Lazar Kaganovich quickly comes to mind and it behooves the Jews and Israel to denounce the crimes of these Jews just as much as it is necessary to denounce the crimes of the Nazis.

Friend, while I agree with the first part of your answer I most definitely disagree with the second. This is untrue and very harmful (to us as well as to the truth) to claim that “Jews” collaborated with “Russians” in atrocities committed by the Soviet Union and thus unwillingly participate in the deception perpetrated (and still perpetrating) by neo-nazis, all kinds of the so called “revisionists” and just simple Jew-Haters. It is an absurd to single out Jews or even Russians from the conglomerate of more than 200 ethnical groups representing population of the Soviet Union when each and every one of them had individuals who contributed to the mentioned by you atrocities. Particularly if majority of Jews and a lot of Russians suffered from those atrocities not less than the others. Don’t mix up “class struggle”, which has no ethnical boundaries, with the racism.

An interesting phenomenon. Poles consider themselves to be victims of the Soviet oppression despite of the fact that huge amount of Poles participated in the Soviet atrocities including Dzerzinski (first chief of the Soviet secret police), Mezinski (second chief of the same police), Vishinski (chief prosecutor during Stalin’s time), etc, not to mention villains inside country: Gomulka, Yaruzelkski, Kirchack and so on. In absolute numbers more Poles participated in communist atrocities than Jews did. However you would never hear any Pole claiming that Poles collaborated with Russians to oppress Eastern European nations. No, you would hear opposite: Poles were victims of that oppression. So, why Jews in the same situation want to act differently? Is that because anti-semites convinced them, unlike Poles, of their guilt?

Mykhayl says:

Nazi and Soviet are both Godless.

Aaron Silverberg says:

Hitler himself was a Jew

Michael J. Berezowsky says:

I note from the photograph of the “presidium” at the anti-Defamation conference in Kyiv that the huge banner is printed in English and Russian, notwithstanding the fact that the conference was held in the capital of Ukraine, an independent country whose official state language is Ukrainian. To me, an American proud of his Ukrainian heritage, this demonstrates a rude disrespect toward Ukrainians by the organizers of the conference. Of course, I would expect that from a Kremlin-sponsored organization, which has apparently been enlisted to lobby for the rebirth of “mighty Russia”.

But Jewish citizens of Ukraine should, I think, learn to RESPECT and SPEAK the Ukrainian language, and should remember that imperial Russia was never a true friend of the Jewish people. For that matter, neither was Soviet Russia.

On a final note, I consider the murder and genocide of ANY people to be despicable and condemnable. Therefore, I see an “equivalence” between the Holocaust and, for example, the Great Famine of 1932-32 in Ukraine perpetrated by the Soviet Government. I hope this does not mean that I am “anti-Semitic”.

From this gathering one gets to know Russian agents of influence on the Western front.

I forewarned they sway off ultrasonic [b]purchase altace prescription on line[ b] sometimes on that gated dosing

[url=http://ordertriactol.buytriactolreviews.org/Triactol-Review---Does-It-Work.html]Triactol Reviews[/url]
[url=http://ordertriactol.buytriactolreviews.org/How-To-Make-Your-Breasts-Grow-Naturally-Using-Triactol-Bust-Serum.html]Trying to find Natural Breast enlargment option Read This Triactol Evaluate[/url]
[url=http://ordertriactol.buytriactolreviews.org/How-To-Get-Best-Results-From-Triactol-Bust-Enhancement-Serum.html]What Is Triactol Breast Serum Good For Just how do This Breast Enhancement Product Help You[/url]
[url=http://ordertriactol.buytriactolreviews.org/What-Is-Triactol.html]Triactol Bust Serum[/url]
[url=http://ordertriactol.buytriactolreviews.org/Triactol-Breast-Serum-Review.html]Triactol Review How Triactol Breast Serum Can Change A Womans Existence[/url]
[url=http://ordertriactol.buytriactolreviews.org/Buy-Triactol-the-Breast-Enlargement-Serum-That-Works.html]Triactol Bust Serum Reviews[/url]
[url=http://ordertriactol.buytriactolreviews.org/Triactol-Bust-Serum-Review.html]Triactol Review So how exactly does Triactol Bust Serum Perform And Can It Really Enlarge The Breasts[/url]
[url=http://ordertriactol.buytriactolreviews.org/Triactol-Serum:-Why-It-Is-Better-Than-Breast-Implants.html]Breast enhancement With Triactol Destroy Serum[/url]
[url=http://ordertriactol.buytriactolreviews.org/Triactol-Organic-Breast-Enhancement-Serums-With-Pueraria-Mirifica-and-Mirifirm.html]Triactol Bust Serum Genuinely Enlarges The Breasts Effortlessly[/url]
[url=http://ordertriactol.buytriactolreviews.org/Find-Out-More-About-Triactol-Breast-Serum---Does-Triactol-Work.html]Triactol Bust Serum Examined[/url]
[url=http://ordertriactol.buytriactolreviews.org/Triactol-Review.html]Triactol Review Do you use it[/url]
[url=http://ordertriactol.buytriactolreviews.org/Triactol-Bust-Serum-Review---Does-Triactol-Really-Work.html]How To Make Your current Breasts Grow Naturally Making use of Triactol Bust Serum[/url]
[url=http://ordertriactol.buytriactolreviews.org/How-To-Ma

[url=http://ordertriactol.buytriactolreviews.org/Triactol-Review---Does-It-Work.html]Triactol Reviews[/url]
[url=http://ordertriactol.buytriactolreviews.org/How-To-Make-Your-Breasts-Grow-Naturally-Using-Triactol-Bust-Serum.html]Seeking Natural Breast enhancer Read This Triactol Review[/url]
[url=http://ordertriactol.buytriactolreviews.org/How-To-Get-Best-Results-From-Triactol-Bust-Enhancement-Serum.html]What Is Triactol Destroy Serum Good For How Can This Breast enhancer Product Enable you to[/url]
[url=http://ordertriactol.buytriactolreviews.org/What-Is-Triactol.html]Triactol Bust Serum[/url]
[url=http://ordertriactol.buytriactolreviews.org/Triactol-Breast-Serum-Review.html]Triactol Assessment How Triactol Destroy Serum Can Change A new Womans Existence[/url]
[url=http://ordertriactol.buytriactolreviews.org/Buy-Triactol-the-Breast-Enlargement-Serum-That-Works.html]Triactol Bust Serum Reviews[/url]
[url=http://ordertriactol.buytriactolreviews.org/Triactol-Bust-Serum-Review.html]Triactol Review So how exactly does Triactol Bust Serum Operate And Can It genuinely Enlarge Your current Breasts[/url]
[url=http://ordertriactol.buytriactolreviews.org/Triactol-Serum:-Why-It-Is-Better-Than-Breast-Implants.html]Breast Enlargement With Triactol Destroy Serum[/url]
[url=http://ordertriactol.buytriactolreviews.org/Triactol-Organic-Breast-Enhancement-Serums-With-Pueraria-Mirifica-and-Mirifirm.html]Triactol Bust Serum Really Enlarges The Breasts Obviously[/url]
[url=http://ordertriactol.buytriactolreviews.org/Find-Out-More-About-Triactol-Breast-Serum---Does-Triactol-Work.html]Triactol Bust Serum Examined[/url]
[url=http://ordertriactol.buytriactolreviews.org/Triactol-Review.html]Triactol Review Do you use it[/url]
[url=http://ordertriactol.buytriactolreviews.org/Triactol-Bust-Serum-Review---Does-Triactol-Really-Work.html]How To Make Your Breasts Develop Naturally Making use of Triactol Bust Serum[/url]
[url=http://ordertriactol.buytriactolreviews.org/How-To-Make-Your-B

If you are open to having a guest web site poster please reply and let me know. I will provide you with unique content material for your web site, many thanks.

I’ve said that least 2147598 times. The problem this like that is they are just too compilcated for the average bird, if you know what I mean

Nice post. I be taught one thing more difficult on totally different blogs everyday. It is going to always be stimulating to read content from other writers and follow somewhat one thing from their store. I’d favor to make use of some with the content material on my blog whether you don’t mind. Natually I’ll offer you a link in your web blog. Thanks for sharing.

baboon says:

I see Russian intelligence started to write about secondary matters (breath enhancement and medicine). This is their beloved tactics to distract.

2000

Your comment may be no longer than 2,000 characters, approximately 400 words. HTML tags are not permitted, nor are more than two URLs per comment. We reserve the right to delete inappropriate comments.

Thank You!

Thank you for subscribing to the Tablet Magazine Daily Digest.
Please tell us about you.

Anti-Anti-Semitism

World Without Nazism is a Kremlin-flavored Anti-Defamation League for the post-Soviet realm—but is it good for Jews?

More on Tablet:

Celebrity Rabbi, Heal Thyself

By Batya Ungar-Sargon — Shmuley Boteach—rabbi, sexpert, Michael Jackson pal—has led many lives. But none of them can obliterate his past.