Your email is not valid
Recipient's email is not valid
Submit Close

Your email has been sent.

Click here to send another

thescroll_header

The Wrong Day to Attack the ‘Forward’

Paper scores victory on day it is accused of bias

Print Email

A version of the following post was accidentally, briefly published without being edited earlier today. The edited version below was to have run tomorrow, but since it has garnered attention, we’re running it now instead.

Yesterday, the Forward announced that George Washington’s 1790 letter to the Hebrew Congregation in Newport, Rhode Island will be displayed next month at the National Museum of American Jewish History.

Congratulations, and no small degree of respect, are due to Paul Berger and our friends at the Forward. Berger tracked down one of the most important documents in American Jewish history—of which even scholars had lost track—in which the first president promised that the new nation would “give to bigotry no sanction, to persecution no assistance,” then, finding the document languishing in a Maryland storage facilility, launched a campaign to get the document displayed to the public.

In what is possibly the worst timing ever, the announcement coincided with a story in the Washington Free Beacon by Adam Kredo citing “insiders” that argued the Forward was a biased publication, without worth, that practice bad journalism.

“They’re so irrelevant to me I don’t even focus on them,” said one Jewish media figure who declined to be named. “I never return the phone call. They’re not on my radar screen—as far as I know, nobody reads them, and they’re totally irrelevant.”

The best (read, worst), part of the story is that many of the “insiders” it cites are people who have come under investigation by the Forward. Nathan Lewin, the lawyer for Shalom Rubashkin, blames the Forward for the fact that his client is currently serving a prison sentence for 86 counts of bank fraud. He also attacks them for investigating the prominent—and, for what it’s worth, shady—Rabbi Yoshiyahu Yosef Pinto. Morton Klein of the Zionist Organization of America attacks the paper for a story suggesting he has bad workplace practices.

Among the other accusations, Kredo suggests the paper faced a “backlash for providing a forum to an American Jewish leader [Kathleen Peratis] who met with Hamas.” The backlash he cites, however, is a story attacking Peratis by … Adam Kredo. The story also accuses the paper of abetting the BDS movement. Here’s a story by Josh Nathan-Kazis noting that BDS has yet to score a victory on U.S. campuses. Here’s an op-ed by editor-in-chief Jane Eisner, attacking the first national conference of the BDS movement. I could go on.

I’m not going to defend the attacked articles, except to say that they’re immaculately sourced. But, since it goes entirely unmentioned in Kredo’s piece, I’d also point out just some of the service done by the Forward, including reporting the compensation of American Jewish communal leaders—like, for instance, Klein, who pulled in $363,462 last year—or bringing light to the underrepresentation of women in their ranks.

This is not the sexy work, but it is essential, worthwhile work that has caused real change in the Jewish world. It is absolutely understandable that if your client is in jail you might hold a grudge—but, I have to say, it doesn’t seem very relevant.

Washington’s Iconic Letter To Be Displayed [Forward]
‘J-Streetpost.com’ [Washington Free Beacon]

Print Email
Cool_Romeo says:

Should Tablet really be pontificating about journalistic ethics after publishing Leibovitz’ piece yesterday that accused, without any substantiation whatsoever, undercover IDF agents of turning peaceful protests into riots?

Physician heal thyself.

yevka says:

Take a dose of your own advise “Cool” Romeo.

Cool_Romeo says:

What do you mean “Yev” ka?

latenight20009 says:

What is the “Washington Free Beacon?” –
who reads it, and why would people with names
care what its un-named sources say?

2000

Your comment may be no longer than 2,000 characters, approximately 400 words. HTML tags are not permitted, nor are more than two URLs per comment. We reserve the right to delete inappropriate comments.

Thank You!

Thank you for subscribing to the Tablet Magazine Daily Digest.
Please tell us about you.

The Wrong Day to Attack the ‘Forward’

Paper scores victory on day it is accused of bias

More on Tablet:

Remembering Margot Adler

By Sara Ivry — NPR anchor passes away at 68